by Carlhole » Thu 25 Sep 2008, 14:46:06
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('cube', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Heineken', 'I') believe in America, but the America I believe in no longer exists.
...
I totally agree.
I think YOU guys are the ones that need to clarify yourselves. Not me.
WTF does this mean? "I believe in America, but the America I believe in no longer exists"
In this thread, we are talking about how Americans typically have had confidence in themselves, their talents, their institutions, their ability to innovate and adapt -- as they look ahead into the future and its challenges.
It's a theme that is always dealt with in historical treatments, in films, in documentaries... Politicians always appeal to this cultural unity as they campaign because it draws people of differing perspectives together. America has a historical, traditional culture and culture is a powerful force in human affairs.
An entrepreneurial spirit is one aspect of American culture of which the nation is most proud and which the nation would most like to maintain as a backbone of our market economy. This is the spirit of innovation. It is a system of rewarding good ideas and new ways of doing things. It is ingrained into American, history and culture.
The whole of this thread is simply an observation that Doomers do not believe in the ability of American culture to adjust and respond to a decline in fossil fuel supply. And even if Doomers are shown a reasonable route that American society might take in order to adapt to a new energy paradigm, Doomers do not believe that America has the will, genius, wisdom, or human energy to make big changes.
I could take more time and lay out a better thumbnail roadmap of energy adaptation as we move into the future but I don't feel like it. Part of my point is that no matter WHAT sort of raodmap is laid before them, Doomers have a reflexive response to all of them. Ridicule and condemn them. Why? Because Doomer's do not believe in America. Actually, they dismiss innovation and adaptability no matter where it is developed - it's just that America has long been and remains a world-class innovator.
Doomers will assure you that only THEY are able to see how the future will unfold. They will assure you that every other view is ignorant and/or delusional. They cannot see how a whole society might adapt and continue making new advancements - even if that adaptation might entail a long-term population reduction and/or a moving away from rampant consumerism.
No. Doomers insist that full societies will fail, fracturing into pale shadows of themselves which progress backwards through time and technology. Nevermind that anyone's certainty about the future is foolish -- Doomers have seen the future and it looks like the past.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Carlhole', 'H')ere's today's relevant article. I find them all the time:
Peak Oil and Nuclear Power Lots of great links to back up the author's main points. Please read it!
Construction of nuclear reactors is OLD technology. This does not take into account energy innovations, conservation and adaptation at all.
Can you prove that fusion energy is entirely impossible? Scientists much more knowledgeable than you are building a very expensive ITER in Europe in order to accomplish that very feat.
Now, I understand that Doomers have absolutely ZERO respect for science or people that chase off after hare-brained ideas like fusion energy. But I think there's a pretty good chance that people will eventually crack that nut. And I think they'll do it before fissionable materials run out - which is many decades.
So, we will continue to use fossil fuels. We will utilize our increasing abundance of natural gas and coal as we build new nuclear plants. As nukes are constructed, we will augment their electricity using renewables and implementing passive and active solar. The price of energy will rise high enough so as to spur conservation as never before. This whole process will play out into the future, possibly decades as research into fusion energy continues apace. Until we have proved that it is impossible, I expect that developing fusion energy will eventually yield to success.
Doomers, however, have about as much faith in the ability of Science to eventually crack the fusion puzzle as they do in the ability of American entrepreneurs to innovate or the American people to adapt.
Doomers do not believe in America.