by Chaparral » Wed 04 Apr 2007, 20:29:53
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('NEOPO', 'C')haparell - one question for you please, when you say that none will give all for justice etc etc do you mean none of the "300" million or none of all the worlds people because I think I could compile a long list of peoples who indeed appeared to give all for these principles.
Now that you mention it, so can I. Perhaps it would be better to say that the vast majority will not lay down their lives for principle. In the face of an overwhelmingly strong state, with nothing to lose by killing dissidents, Satyagraha, martyrdom or other things may not be so effective. In a declining empire, where the control of the elites would start to weaken or if the elites were to fragment, such heroism may indeed buy time for the extant generation. I'm assuming that the elites are in charge, don't give a damn about the planet, powerdown or other peoples' futures and wish only to hold on to their power as the world slides down Olduvai Gorge.
If the "paradigm" is the enemy and some of the elites recognize that, and are willing to power down, then perhaps the equation would change and a few principled individuals could move nations (with tacit consent of at least "some of the authority").
In the scenario that PMS puts forth, I suspect there would be significantly fewer willing to sacrifice themselves or their children based on principle. Keep in mind that I am hewing strictly to PMS's parameters and discounting powerdown, Uppsala depletion protocols etc etc. I am also assuming a populace that is as gg3 states "this world oriented" as opposed to being "next world oriented" but even then, heavenly reward would probably provide a greater impetus to self-sacrifice than a Kantian appeal to duty or a purely secular appeal to justice.
Ooooh! "300" million was a bad farking number to use (I was thinking the US pop. Fark! Now that I think about it, there may be more to that movie timing and title than meets the eye. Those pretty wheat fields of Sparta were tended by slaves you know. It could be argued that the Spartans were the elites where the graphic novel and the movie conveniently left the real source of labor in that society unmentioned.....food for thought. The clash of the 300 was merely a clash of elites? Where the lot of the slaves would remain unchanged? Oh, the layered possibilites!
WRT to "24", I don't own a TV and AFAIC, that show is no reason for me to buy one.