by Nearinempty » Fri 08 Jun 2007, 22:49:35
For the sake of national security and greenhouse gas reduction it is critical that petroleum imports be lowered and the transportation system be transitioned to cleaner, sustainable fuels. Pending legislation raising vehicle fuel economy standards might help to achieve these goals, but by itself is insufficient and would likely prove to be counter-productive. Not only would new compliant vehicles take many years to replace the current fleet, but making driving less expensive would be a perverse incentive to actually increase total demand. Even now, with higher gas prices imposing the most inequitable form of rationing, most consumers still seem willing to pay almost any price to continue habits which for too many involve unconscious, avoidable waste. The resulting scarcity pricing impacts adversely throughout the economy, particularly on the poor and marginally profitable enterprises.
These failures of current and proposed methods for limiting gasoline consumption clearly demonstrate the need for a means to actually lower TOTAL domestic gasoline consumption and stimulate a transition to cleaner sustainable fuels.
How might this be achieved without coupons, a new government bureaucracy, or black markets? One way is to begin right at the gas pump and capitalize on the normal human desire to avoid unnecessary time, effort, and cost to fuelup. In our time-pressured society, busy gasoline customers might undertake unaccustomed responses to be able to both complete their transaction quickly and not have to repeat it any sooner than absolutely necessary. If the amount of gasoline they could readily obtain was limited, they might be moved to avoid wasteful driving practices and thereby reduce their personal consumption, and thus collective demand.
Using presumed technology to implement the program, each RETAIL HIGHWAY GASOLINE pump would be reprogrammed (ideally per federal legislation for uniformity) to dispense no more than 15 gallons to a given credit/debit card(s) owner in a 24 hour period. Drivers wanting/needing more could move to a different pump, or go inside the gas station to pay cash (in advance) for up to another 15 gallons. Pumps dispensing blends of biodiesel or ethanol (greater than e15),as well as marine, aviation, or private pumps would be totally exempt from limitation. Initially, straight petrodiesel pumps would also be exempt, to help expand the market for using vehicles.
All drivers without exception would face the choice of making 15 gallons do through personal conservation the job previously done by more, or else spending additional time, effort, and money to get more gas. Arguably the people who value time and convenience most highly are most likely to have higher consuming vehicles. Regardless, all would be motivated to consider their use of gasoline and the benefits of fuel-efficient and alternative vehicles- thereby stimulating the market to provide them.
To continue the stimulative effect, the initial 15 gallon limit would be annually reduced by one gallon.
There are numerous advantages and benefits to such a plan:
1) The beneficial effects following implementation would begin immediately. Gasoline prices should respond to the resulting lower demand by falling, benefiting the overall economy.
2) Impact of this program is spread equitably across the population, rather than hardest on the poor and marginally profitable businesses.
2) Consumer choice of vehicles is not directly dictated by implementation. Drivers could opt to
continue driving large / high consumption vehicles merely by taking the time and effort necessary to fuel them.
3) Overall accident rates and severity should decline in conjunction with lower average speeds.
4) Gasoline retailers would benefit through increased sales from their high profit snack area by additional cash customers.
5) The market for higher efficiency and alternative fueled vehicles would be stimulated beyond what it would otherwise be, leading to accelerated development and employment in the fuel and vehicle industries.
DISCLAIMER: The pump programming features required by the proposed method are inferred from reports of individual dealer and credit card company purchase limitations, and may require further development to actually achieve.