by thuja » Sun 20 May 2007, 14:12:10
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Ender', '
')
There will be efficiency gains in various senses: passenger cars will get smaller (ie. you Americans will be driving little Smartcars like the Europeans and Japanese have been doing for years), hybrids will proliferate, technology will advance, people will drive less. You have a very negative outlook on the ability of humanity to adjust to change. Bear in mind that our great-grandparents lived their lives through the use of virtually no oil at all. We'll have much more access to it than they did.
Ender I am glad that you are still contributing to PO.com---as of late it has become the purview of uber-doomers who propose collapse in a matter of a few years. They seem to rule the roost right now. Soft-landers are a rare breed around here so I want to respect your opinion even if I don't entirely agree with you.
In some ways you are right- the First World will find ways to make adjustments in the initial phases- we have survived two world wars and the Great Depression without civilization collapsing and I seriously doubt we will experience any collapse scenarios like the uber-doomers profess in the next 20 years.
The problem is that you seem to discount the idea that global oil production will deplete at a very conservative rate of 2-3% a year once we come off the plateau. At that rate, we will have to deal with ongoing and escalating shortages until we literally have no oil to produce with the span of a few decades.
We are talking about an escalating, intensifying and unabating crisis. Though I am hopeful for a transition to a lower tech, deeply energy conservative society- my heart knows that this cannot happen without overwhelming distress and chaos in many parts of the world.
We are seeing these elements of chaos and warfare in many parts of the world right now...Iraq, Nigeria, Sudan, Somalia, etc., are all experiencing massive chaos due to resource competition. How do you see the First World escaping this fate as resources such as oil, natural gas and water deplete rapidly over the next few decades?