by TheDude » Wed 17 Feb 2010, 13:14:18
Thanks for the very interesting reply, gogh. For those interested:
My MBTI Personality Type - MBTI Basics - The 16 MBTI Types. Hey, ISTJ's first listed! Me, George Washington, QE2, George HW Bush. Yech. "This aggression will not stand!"
You were referring to Stuart's Fallacy of Reversibility article, right? As you might expect, I come down on his side there too, barring a total slide backwards. They tried the Nation of Farmers thing in GD France, with very mixed results. More likely if we are facing a Japan style Lost Decade(s) in the US growing your own food will become popular for many out of economic necessity, along with developing alternative forms of MT, i.e., grey market jitnies, vanpooling, boring stuff like that.
But farming benefits from scale, it seems to me. The actual machinery uses such a small segment of fuel consumed; farmers can resort to growing a plot of soybeans for biodiesel if it came to that. The shipping fuel costs are another matter, of course; perhaps industrial ag will hold on but become more localized? But millions of bent backs? Plow horses? Sounds like a great neo WPA but it wouldn't be an effective way to farm, we have too much viable knowledge about machinery at this stage.
Kerosene:
Anne Dilenschneider: Help Light Haiti (Huff Po)
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'S')omething we often take for granted -- lighting - is essential for safety and security, self-empowerment and self-sufficiency. Even before the earthquake, 85% of Haitians did not have electricity. Now the situation is even worse. You can help. For $10, you can empower a group of 10 people in Haiti for 10 years by providing a solar-powered light.
SunNight Solar has been providing solar-powered flashlights to the people of Haiti for over 4 years. There are reports that the lights already in Haiti at the time of the earthquake, and the 150 delivered by former President Clinton, are allowing neighbors to help each other in the aftermath. There is story after story of these lights being used to save lives.
Through its BoGo Lights ("Buy one, Give one") program, SunNight Solar donates solar-powered flashlights to schools and hospitals and homes throughout the world where electricity is unreliable. It also provides lights to women in refugee camps, because reliable light is essential for the safety and security of women and children who otherwise might be attacked at night.
I'm not a student on Haiti's woes, didn't catch the article TOD had on Haiti's energy. My assumption was the bulk of the land use degradation as depicted in that pic of the Haiti/DR border was from industrial deforestation unhampered by regulation in any form.
As with anything else I'd figure poverty would be the big factor in inability to acquire propane, just like with food. Looking at the EIA charts for annual spot prices of the stuff (incl Europe) it roughly tracks the crude price, peaking sharply in '08, instead of being a negative correlative to UNG as a fraction of US NG supply.
The earthquake would have an obvious impact too. Is this a secular trend?
Also: I'm more on board with Greer's scenarios than anyone else. I do believe things will backslide, just on the scale of centuries, barring our collectively getting our act together. It's a huge system with enormous inertia in it, and tech plays a real role - consider how much oil is sourced from deepwater now, which was unthinkable as recently as the 1960's. But this doesn't mean we can keep crapping on the planet for millennia on end, barring our evolving into intelligent machines, or colonizing space and bidding farewell, or turning the place into one big park.