by mos6507 » Sat 06 Feb 2010, 18:45:47
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('pstarr', '
')Higher oil prices preceded the recession. Not an embargo, not a war in the mideast, etc. What preceded both this world-wide financial crisis and the mortgage crisis? ONE BIG F#CKING EVENT. you know but you refuse to here it.
What preceded the recession was a huge wave of liar loans given to people who had NO HOPE of paying their mortgages after the ARMs reset. And those mortgages were bundled together into fraudulent "AAA" financial products that were then sold across the globe. It was the equivalent of a financial biological weapon. Once the stage was set, the end result was unavoidable.
By 2007, the pool of buyers for housing had diminished so much because those who wanted had already bought in, or housing prices had appreciated so far that even teaser loans would not yield an acceptable monthly fee. And around that time, the foreclosures began.
Did people pay more to commute from the exurbs? Did this apply downard pressure on exurban house prices? Did the failure of GM and Chrysler and the ailing airlines matter? Yes, but if you removed all those factors, the end result would have been much the same.
There was no further inflation of the housing bubble possible. $10 oil would not have allowed another round of housing mania. It was gonna pop, period.
This has been my claim all along, and you dispute it. Peak oil neophytes like Jeff Rubin who are more interested in waving the "Soylent Green is Peeple" flag than really getting down and dirty into the data say what you want to hear, but it just doesn't hold up under scrutiny.
Remove $147/oil and the credit crisis still happens and (IMHO) would have been pretty much just as bad as it turned out with $147/oil.
The credit crisis was more than sufficient to cause the situation that we have today. I say this not as a "peak oiler" but as a rational independent thinker. I will not let peak oil bias me into placing the oil superspike (which, let's face it, was partly driven by speculation) to the center stage as the causative factor of the recession.
Throwing ad homs my way will just get your posts flagged.