by Heineken » Mon 16 Jun 2008, 08:45:56
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('mos6507', 'D')ecimation of a single industry has happened before. What happened to the buggy whip makers when cars took over in the first place? How about the makers of typewriters when computers took over? What tends to happen is the jobs lost in one sector pop up in a new or growing sector. There are going to be jobs for mechanics converting cars to electric, jobs for solar panel installers, jobs for people putting up windmills, jobs for people laying down tracks to restore rail lines, construction jobs lost to the housing crunch may be restored with people needing to retrofit their shoddy homes for energy efficiency. People just have to adapt. I went to college studying film production but I wound up making a career in the dot com space. I had to change with the times even without peakoil. That's the way it's been for a while now. It's generally expected that people have to be able to shift careers once or twice in their lifetimes.
Sometimes people just have such a negative vibe about peakoil that they can't comprehend the idea that the downward trajectory might not be as steep or as universal as their internal vision. It's not mutually exclusive. We can still experience zombie hordes and die offs but pass through transitional stages along the way.
Overall I disagree with these comments, Mos. They assume that we are infinitely adaptable.
This time it's different, and just switching jobs won't fix it.
This is not about the decimation of a single industry, as you said. We're talking about well-nigh every facet of economic activity, from agriculture to the zoology department at your local university. Oil runs through and connnects them all like a needle and thread.
All those "alternative" industries you list are to various degrees oil-dependent. And if not oil, then coal. What do you think locomotives run on, both in their engines and under their wheels? How will those solar-panel installers get to their job sites? What about their lunchtime---what will they eat and what will it cost? What about the long chain of manufacturing that produces finished solar panels?
Sometimes I wish the name of this website was not Peak Oil but Peak Energy. Because that's what we're really talking about. A decline in net energy availability for the first time in human history.
Wait until we hit Peak Electricity. Coming soon. Then people won't talk so carelessly about electric this and electric that.