by abbcampbell » Tue 20 Dec 2005, 14:36:39
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('crapattack', ']')
I wasn't aware you needed to be an expert to have an option on a forum such as this abbcampbell. I have a graduate level degree in Psychology, and I'm learning all I can about PO, but I don't know if you would consider me an expert on this topic. I doubt it and I don't feel like one in any case.
No, of course you don't need to be an expert to have an opinion. Most folks have opinions. Many very brilliant people, however, suffer from "smart persons' disease." They are quite knowledgable in one subject, and recognize the fact that many people are not particularly knowledgable in any. This can lead them to a false sense of certainty about all subjects. I see it all the time. For instance, an aquaintance who is a leading authority on raptors assuming he can rewire his office... Fortunately it only took an electrican, and not the fire department, to undo what he did.
Of course, experts can also be wrong within their subject. As a non-expert, though, my best bet is to listen to those who are, and do my best to judge from there.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'O')nce you see the full context I think you'll agree it is quite clear I was stating my own opinion.
Yep. Never thought you weren't.
As for Jevon's Paradox, I'm reasonably familiar with it. I honestly don't feel it applies here, though. Jevon's Paradox just points to efficiency in coal use causing greater use of coal. No problems there. I could see that applying to oil as well in certain circumstances... On the other hand, Jevons' observations were not of a people intentionally trying to conserve a resource.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'K')unstler is indeed a journalist, he's written several books, "The Long Emergency" was one. From what I've seen I imagine he would most strongly disagree with you that he advocates new-urbanism. But a lot of your other observations were close if not bang on.