Gentlemen,
Now that we are down to brass tacks I feel I know where I stand.
Clearly Jack I do not agree with your diagnosis or prescription which appears to be that we Nice White People, having dragooned and coerced the other 80% of the world into and unjust and unsustainable global empire of deprivation, slavery and misery, should just stand aside and let them all starve to death by the billions.
Not only is this morally repugnant, I believe it to be based on a mistaken view of history and human nature.
To say that everyone at all times have been driven by an unslakable thirst for material advancement and social climbing is to put the values of our own very sick society onto the past.
In point of fact most people throughout time, to judge from their actions, have been content to raise their families on their little plot of land taking the good with the bad and striving to stay out of trouble. Generally speaking they have only rebelled when misgovenment, oppression and warfare have prevented them from going about their humble lives for long periods of time.
The uncontrolled materialist aquisitiveness of today is actually a piece of Right-Wing social engineering executed by the corporate mass-media for three generations and at vast expense, not a natural outcome of human nature. Were people presented with more relaxed values and aspirations, most I feel would, with a sigh of relief, be happy to embrace the ways of their ancestors.
Monte, I like your aspect better as it close to my own. Yes there will be a depression, that is unquestionable; it is how we react that matters.
One thing history had taught me is that in some respects history is a bad guide to the future: it is full of surprises and unpredicable events. Who could have foreseen the French Revolution, the Industrial Revolution or the Reformation?
For that matter who could have forseen the Humanitarian Conscience, the Green Movement, Feminism or the Counterculture? If you are worried the 100% Enviromentalism is unlikely then all I can say is that stranger things have happened.
To imagine that what we are bound to endlessly repeat the past makes as much sense as to say that just because I had cornflakes for breakfast yesterday I am compelled to have them for breakfast this morning.
We are in for some more suprises, and some of them will be pleasant. For this reason I am guardedly optimistic, and it is forums like this, preparing the way for a future that will not be wholly dark, that help to make me so.
