by MonteQuest » Thu 09 Feb 2006, 23:22:07
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Eli', 'W')hat disturbs me the most with all this talk about alternatives is the complete lack of discusion about rethinking our transport system and no real talk about conservation.
We are addicted to oil but we are not talking seriously about cutting back on our habit, it is all about other stuff that will get us high too.
Therein lies the rub: We cannot continue to do what we do, but just less so. Conservation can be a bridge to a steady state economy, but studies I have read point to a 25% conservation effort being eclipsed by population growth alone in 13 years. Conservation under our current model only postpones, then accelerates and excaerbates the pain of correction back to an equillibrium.
Conservation is also a self-induced recession as
somebody has to absorb the loss in economic activity.
Yes, we should have a big discussion on a shift from long-haul trucking to rail and mass transit to ease the need for private autos. But next time you go out in rush hour traffic, think about the
scale of that change.
Most solutions are focused short-term; how can I get my mine while the getting is stll somewhat good?
Cutting back on the habit does little if you don't plan on kicking it in the end.

And Revi is right; in nature there is no such thing as waste. Burning soil nutrients for engine fuel just makes us more dependent upon inorganic fertilizers.
Roscoe Bartlett on C-Span yesterday:
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'T')he other caution is, how much biomass can we take from our land and still have topsoil? With all of our good techniques today, no till farming and so forth, every bushel of corn we grow in Iowa is accompanied by three bushels of topsoil that go down the Mississippi River.
Now, topsoil is topsoil, rather than subsoil simply because it has organic matter in it. And that organic matter, the humus comes from decaying organic material. And if you are taking all that organic material off to burn or to ferment or whatever you are going to do with it, I am not certain how long we can maintain the quality of our topsoil so that we can continue to produce the food and fiber that we need and that the world needs.