by Tyler_JC » Wed 10 Dec 2008, 18:45:31
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'W')hile supporting the concept that healthy adults should be able to use brain-boosting drugs, the authors called for:
_ More research into the use, benefits and risks of such drugs. Much is unknown about the current medications, such as the risk of dependency when used for this purpose, the commentary said. Also, according to the Food and Drug Administration, Adderall, for example, is an amphetamine that carries warnings about possible sudden death, heart attack and stroke, especially for people with heart problems.
_ Policies to guard against people being coerced into taking them.
_ Steps to keep the benefits from making socio-economic inequalities worse.
_ Action by doctors, educators and others to develop policies on the use of such drugs by healthy people.
_ Legislative action to allow drug companies to market the drugs to healthy people if they meet regulatory standards for safety and effectiveness.
Here's a link directly to the AP Article.
Here's a counter argument to your criticism.
Lots of people take Ginseng, St. John's Wort, or Seaweed. Others take Vitamin C or Vitamin E supplements. Some drink green tea and do yoga.
The entire "alternative medicine" movement is based on eating healthy and taking herbal supplements as opposed to commercial pharmaceuticals.
What is the difference between taking a natural stimulant like St. John's Wort or an artificial stimulant like Adderal?
There isn't much difference between most "alternative" medicines and main stream medicines.
Is drinking caffeinated coffee in order to boost your alertness any different than taking a No-Doz?
The guy isn't calling for everyone to immediately start downing Ritalin like Tic Tacs, he's saying that we should study the risks/benefits of taking the drugs.
We legally allow purchase and use as much St. John's Wort as they want, why not explore the possibility of allowing more free choice in the pharmaceuticals market?
If there is a proven benefit that exceeds the risk, I see no reason to stop consumers from having the opportunity to improve their mental capabilities.