by wisconsin_cur » Mon 01 Dec 2008, 03:26:57
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ReverseEngineer', '[')
Well first off, Peak Oil insures that eventually here, Human Beings will never be able to get THIS fat and roll over their britches quite so much as now, so that in itself is hopeful news. Regardless of what you perceive to be the inherent nature of human beings, if the environment and resources won't support so large a population, you won't have near the amount of Evil growing that results from that. That is a direct consequence of your own observation.
Second, I disgree that there is nothing we can do to promote human beings moving toward a higher level of consciousness and personal responsibility. That is what you must TEACH to your children, so that this is what gets passed on to the survivors, NOT the tendency toward Greed and Selfishness. If you regard this as immutable and universal, it will of course never change, its your EXPECTATION that it will never change. Children live up to the expectations of the adults who surround them,if yours are low, then your children will live up to the lowest of them, guaranteed.
Will you or I ever see a better world in our lifetimes? I hardly think so, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't preach what is Good to our children, or that we shouldn't be angry about the sad state the world is in now either. I personally am damn angry about this, and I have no issues with saying so either, regardless of what the DSM IV might say about this aspect of my personality.
Its not important what comes about in my lifetime, its what I stand for now that counts, and what I preach. I won't see the results of it here in this life, but I will see it from the Great Beyond.
See You on the Other Side
Reverse Engineer
The Roman Empire, Spanish, Aztec, British etc etc empires were plenty evil and they did not need oil to be so.
Yes you can train your children but that is no guarentee how they will turn out let alone how their great-grandchildren will turn out. Some people come out of awful childhoods to become quite reflective some grow up with every spiritual advantage and are not. Part of a good life is to do what you can to tutor those who will take your place in the future but each of the students that truly takes up the task will live in a world much like ours with about the same ratio of enlightenment vs base behavior among the population as a whole.
Again show me a communtiy that has raised its children right in such a way as to weed out greed out of the population as a whole... you already confessed that it does not exist. You have that great human secularist eschatology which is as faith-based as my theistic one (which I do not talk about here because it is faith-based). "If only we teach out children right they will..." I see no evidence that they will and since I do not share the secular-humanist hope for the
inhierent transcendence of human character I lay that hope where it belongs, with the divine.
And since it is the job of the divine to manage the meta-narrative of the species I can busy myself with those things that I really can control. Faithful living in the present world as I find it. Part of that is public; mostly it is private. And at the end of the day I am too tired to worry about what everyone else is doing. This is good because the first impulse of empire building is an over-concern with everyone else's business.
Small scale (ie the Amish) maybe you can train for sustainability but a close reading of their history will reveal they are not immune and the seductions of power and greed that they face... I have little doubt that if they had the potential to become empire builders they would, over time, re-enact they cycle of imperial ambition. As it is, they do a pretty good job of minding their own business and trying to form communities of faithful living.