by TWilliam » Tue 14 Oct 2008, 13:05:35
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Carlhole', ''')Zeitgeist Addendum' is very pro energy technology - especially geothermal energy.
It's been my understanding so far that geothermal energy was a marginal, niche player in the total breakdown from all sources. However, Zeitgeist claims that it can potential dwarf all others.
After I watched it, I noticed thaqt there is at east one thread here on PO.com which speaks well of the potential of geothermal.
The producer of this film may not be the sharpest energy expert in the drawer but he at least does a little due diligence before spouting off an opinion and going to all the expense and effort of making a film. But the people he chose to interview seemed to be political types way over on the Left. Whereas I would have preferred to hear from engineering types who held a reasonable vision for geothermal... or solar or wind or whatever.
What's the realistic potential of geothermal energy?
You have to be able to engineer extremely strong bore holes in order to withstand the immense pressures at depths of 10 - 20 miles into the crust - except in certain places on Earth where the crust is thin.
Keep in mind tho' Carl the title of these two films:
Zeitgeist. The major point is that we need an entirely new
vision of who and what we humans are as a species, of what a truly
civilized society looks like and how it functions.
IMO their major shortcoming is that, while the producer does a wonderful job of illustrating
why this is the case --why the old frameworks of religion, capitalism and politics no longer serve the evolution of our species (if they ever really did in the first place)-- there is little offered as far as any kind of roadmap for moving forward. I suppose this is understandable, given that we're talking about uncharted territory.
Jacque Fresco's 'Venus Project' (featured in the second film) offers a beautiful and tempting vision of possibilities, similar in many ways it appears to Paolo Soleri's 'Arcology' ideas. Unfortunately, I think it's highly unlikely that we'll ever get the opportunity to pull off any such variation on The Jetsons...

"It means buckle your seatbelt, Dorothy, because Kansas? Is goin' bye-bye... "