by MrBill » Wed 04 Jun 2008, 05:03:19
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('vision-master', 'S')ince when is social security and medicaid social welfare programs? People pay into these programs their whole working life.
But they withdraw more in benefits than they pay in. And compounding of payments in depends on growth in capital markets that depend on real economic growth net of inflation. In real terms you can only withdraw 100% of what you put in. That means work a year to retire a year only with 100% taxation. Not work 35-40 years and live until you are 75-80 in combination with paying 35% in taxes. That leaves 40-years where you are consuming, but not contributing.
Of course, for the first 18-20 years you are likely living off your parents, but they do not pay taxes on your behalf even though you consume public income in the form of education and healthcare. Civil servants can typically retire after 30-years service at the age of 55. The military after just twenty years of active service. Young enough to eventually collect a second pension if they want.
Also, the workforce is never 100% of the population. So persons withdraw benefits that they have never contributed to. For example survival benefits paid out to spouses. Those under a certain income threshold pay little or no tax, but still collect benefits and use public services. A cost to society.
As the system is now it is social welfare and wealth redistribution, and is not a self-funding insurance scheme or self-funded pension scheme. You are getting a free ride on the back of today's workforce. It was designed that way.
The organized state is a wonderful invention whereby everyone can live at someone else's expense.