by wisconsin_cur » Mon 30 Jun 2008, 01:49:26
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('OilFinder2', 'B')ut w_c, golly gee, I thought speculators and investors weren't supposed to have an effect on the commodities markets. You mean to tell me that if lots of people take Mr. Roger's advice and buy into commodities, that will have no effect on the price?
I guess we've got shortages of gold, too, since Mr. Rogers is advising to buy it . . . in spite of the fact that
world gold consumption is down 16% in the first quarter of this year.
In case you haven't noticed, prices have been going up long before Jim Rogers opened his mouth.
Why don't you show us one of the charts you like to flash. You know the one where food production is barely keeping up with demand. Then well discuss the effect of the floods on midwest food production and the fact that we added something along the lines of 200k mouths to feed today.
Speculators chase rising prices, they do not instigate them.
Oil Speculator Myth
CNN: Don't blame the speculators
You quote Rogers as a sign of something bad, but ignore what he has to say or his track record. He called gold @ 1000 an oz in april of 2006
when it was ~700 an oz. It then went into a sharp decline. How did that happen if he was driving a "bubble"? But then it went up because he was correct on the fundamentals.
People see the direction things are going and they invest accordingly. If I had the money, I would too. The tech bubble resulted because the world was buying a lot of tech and there were a lot of new things out there that might work. At some point it became overbought and the bubble grew and then burst. Because it ended in a bubble does not mean that there was not a real increase in demand initially.
The bubble burst when supply outgrew demand (and a lot of companies could not provide on their promises).
So the question remains, will the current high prices bring on more supply of food and oil and eventually burst a bubble? There can be different answers to that question (and I think we both know where the other stands). But if more supply of either come on-line it is going to be because higher prices, illicitied by a genuine manifestation of tight supply, brings on more production.
We have a tight supply, your own little graphs say as much. So prices are going up.