by Chesire » Fri 29 Feb 2008, 11:46:53
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Dukkha', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'Y')our logic fails reality. The question at present is can 10 US folks feed themselves and 1000 others today and 2000 tomorrow. Remember the 1000 you refered to aren't contributing to the food supply only the demand. From an ecologically point of view 10 US feeding only themselves causes far less damage than feeding themselves and 1000 others.
To a certain extent that's obviously true: that is, it's less of a burden on the planet to feed 10 people than it is to feed 1000 people. However, it's clearly not true that "the 1000 you refered to aren't contributing to the food supply only the demand" (do you
really think Bangladeshis grow no food?) and also my choice was not between 10 Americans and 10 Americans with 1000 Bangladeshis. It was between 10 Americans and 1000 Bangladeshis and taken in the round, I'd rather have 1000 Bangladeshis living than 10 Americans. Now clearly, there is a fair amount of hyperbole in my question but the point is this: By restricting questions to the population/food nexus, it's possible (and it's no accident that it happens constantly on this website) to overlook to calamitous imposition which Americans (and British, and Japanese, and French) place upon the environment. The regularity with which threads like this is depressing (but explicable) because it offloads the responsibilities of imbeciles like Cheshire onto the "3rd-world". "It's their fault! It's their fault!" they shout but it's not. It's your fucking fault and it's my fucking fault. This isn't, of course, to say that population growth in the global south is not a problem but it's a problem which needs to be seen in perspective.
Where exactly did I post that it wasn't my fault ? Of course its my fault for being a winner in the geographical birth lottery . Then again if you are not a hunter - gatherer you too are art of the problem. Since h/g people are not noted for being internet savvy I suggest you go rent an industrial strength winch and use it to remove your head from your ass . You sanctimonius cunt.
I am firmly in the camp of how to divide 6.3 billion people from their resources and come up with 300 million americans left over
In fact I use extra water every day just to ensure some poor mexicans bastards go without at the end of the Colorado river.
Doing my part to clean up the gene pool one wasted drop at a time.