by killJOY » Fri 23 Nov 2007, 12:20:53
Bakhtiari is among my top three favorite analysts: Deffeyes, Campbell and he, among the old-timers.
He brought a palpable dignity to the "doomer" vision: his message was that catastrophic change is coming and we should choose to take it like adults.
He has what I think is the best moment in End of Suburbia:
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', '"')God does set his own limits. I believe he likes to test human kind from time to time. And I think the test is going to come very, very soon."
Listening to Bakhtiari, one could almost feel good about embracing the change that is to come. This isn't doomerism so much as maturity.
Seeing that he has died, and seeing the newest raft of "skeptical" arguments (actually denialist articles) against peak oil, I grow more convinced that, while the peak oil argument has been won, the peak oil CAUSE is lost.
We're still arguing about WHETHER peak oil is coming. But Bakhtiari notable told us that
"the modeling phase is over."He drew vicious attacks from frothers (who shall remain nameless), I think because his vision was so bracing: We most decidedly could not have our cake and eat it too.
Who is going to fill his shoes?
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Ali Samsam Bakhtiari', '[')T]here is no time left to prepare public opinion for 'Post Peak' sequels. The shocks will first surprise, then jilt, and finally entangle swaths of people worldwide. Those better prepared will be less inclined to react in a disorderly way and panic when the shocking truth will be unveiled.