by MrBill » Tue 28 Aug 2007, 04:07:56
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('BigTex', 'M')r. Bill,
Are you still thinking Bull Trap?
When an anticipated rate cut is all that is keeping the market going, that's not good.
Yes, very much so. This is the anticipated 'return to normal' part of the Bull Trap as per that chart that I posted on the previous page. But as you say, so far all that has rescued the market from fear and then capitulation has been coordinated central bank intervention, and that is a shaky foundation on which to build a rally.
I am thinking to now sell some more energy stocks. We have bounced from 485 to 533 on the S&P Energy Index or almost 10%, but yesterday ended on a down note despite a pick-up in crude prices. That is not very promising. 519-522 is my pivot point. Below that I do not like it at all.
Also, EUR/JPY (my proxy for risk) is down again as yen strengthens on the back on carry trades unwinding. EUR/JPY did not take out the psychological 160 level on the upside. Resistance is 159.66 and support is 157.20 with secondary support at 155.95 on the daily chart. A reversal would see us re-testing the previous low at 149.25 on the way to 146.50 which is the 50% retracement of the move higher in EUR/JPY that started in 2003 at 124. EUR/JPY went from 88.80 to 124 between 2000 and 2003.
My point being that EUR/JPY (representing two major producing and exporting economies) has traveled a long ways and a reversal of 169 to 149 is significant if you happen to be short yen, but in the great scheme of things is a correction that was bound to happen eventually.
The S&P 500 is having trouble holding on to weak gains. I see resistance at 1480 and temporary support at 1455 and 1447. Below 1450 and I think we will gravitate towards 1371 again. As hopes of a Fed rate cut begin to fade, or at least be objectively questioned, this will erode support for a miracle return to normal despite serious problems in the US domestic housing market and still deteriorating credit conditions. The latest forecasts I am reading point to a 15-20% fall in the real value of homes including inflation between now and 2009, and perhaps 8 to 10 years before homes re-hit previous peaks.
Those are just estimates and you can figure in your own post peak oil depletion scenarios on top of those baseline forecasts, but it does not support, in my opinion, a quick return to business as usual. We still do not even know the extent on the subprime mess and that is just the tip of the credit iceberg as far as I am concerned.
I was talking to an Austrian bank with $9 billion in fixed income under management. I was shocked that such a conservative bank would have exposure to US subprime, but like many others they had bought AAA CDO tranches thinking they were safe.
I will not even start to talk about the incompetence of the German Landesbanks. State-run savings banks that had no business speculating in US subprime mortgages or complex financial derivatives. Let us just say these Landesbanks have a long history of making very large risky bets that have a habit of blowing up in their faces. Each crisis piles on to the one before, so that they are forced to merge under duress with one another instead of carefully planning much needed consolidation in the German banking system. Simply too many banks all chasing low domestic margins.
WestLB, one of the largest and most international of the Landesbanks, announces its Q2'07 results today. Estimates are that they may be exposed to high risk loans to the tune of $500 million, but I have also heard estimates of up to $3 billion. Compared to Sachsen LB that would be a drop in the proverbial bucket, but none the less comes on the heels of a long string of bad lending decisions for West LB, so I will not be surprised if today only reaffirms poor risk management control and supervision at this savings bank.
I expect Bayerische Landesbank to be the next to admit they have bad loans in their portfolio. Another bank that wobbles from one disaster to another.
The major German banks - Deutsche, Commerzbank, Dresdner and HVB (Unicredito) all have their own problems in the crowded German market, but all are much stronger than the Landesbanks and/or have strong parent firms that can financially back them. Still, Commerzbank of the five looks particularly vulnerable to an eventual take-over, so if overall problems drive down share prices it may the next to go.
So to make a long story short, no, I do not think that a poorly timed interest rate cut on behalf of the Fed or other central banks is going to magically solve all these systemic problems stemming from mismanagement, poor strategy and mispricing risk. And the insurance companies and asset managers are likely the next shoes to drop heavily. All that such monetary policy relaxing can do is re-ignite inflationary pressures elsewhere even if domestic demand is weak or expected to fall.
As for the options pricing story, I really not have time to chase it down at the moment. I do not know how transparent large option trades are to the rest of the market? I assume any trades struck on an exchange are recorded. Any done over the counter (OTC) are not publicly traded information and proprietary in nature. The story certainly has not been picked-up yet by Reuters, Bloomberg, the FT or Wall Street Journal, so it may be just a red herring. Another Internet prank.
If you expected a market crash and a pick-up in volatility then you would want to buy OTM puts, so that they would increase in value as the price moves towards your strike and their volatility increases. The puts would gain in value even if your strike price was not triggered. But of course you would have to sell them before expiry if they were still OTM to salvage your premium. One month puts would have a pretty high time value decay in the last couple of weeks to maturity. If they were close to ATM by that time you might find a buyer, if not they would be quite invaluable. Why not sell S&P futures (short the indices with or without leverage) instead and save the premium, but achieve the same goal?
All good questions, but back to work here. I am filling the funding sandbags and boarding up my stock portfolio ahead of any financial storms that may hit Cape Fear in the next few weeks. I am predicting an active Blow Off season as a stronger than usual El Capitulation may herald the Winter of our Despair.
The organized state is a wonderful invention whereby everyone can live at someone else's expense.