by SILENTTODD » Sat 19 May 2007, 04:14:06
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrMambo', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('SILENTTODD', 'I') have always maintained it will not be the primary sources or generators that collapse first in the Electrical/ Telco. It will be the infrastructure. The wires, the cables, the repeaters.
Unless there is the legion of field technicians that with their gas guzzling trucks available; most of the infrastructure will disappear within a year.
Water may last longer, I know nothing about it. But I do know the water purification systems rely on electricity. So take your choice which is most vulnerable.
I don't know how you back up your claims. When peak oil hits.. it wont be like 90% is gone in a year, it will be more like 1-3%. How large do you think the "legion" of technicians really are say in the USA? 500 000 people? A million people? Even with 2 million infrastructure technicians that will be less than one percent of the US population. And since most americans drive large SUV's already I don't see that the grid maintanance is all that energy demanding and oil demanding, relatively.
The only way you will have "most of the infrastructure will disappear within a year" is for there to be massive physical attacks on the powerlines and the related infrastructure from som sort of wild mob.
So do you think that the mob will destroy the grid? Or do you think 100-200 dollar/barrel oil will do it. Me I don't think its probable that any of those will finish the grid. Rather I think people will start taking better care of the grid.
Hadn’t had a chance to review posts on this till today,
Mr. MrMambo, I back up my claims from 10 years experience as an at&t DS1 Provisioning, and now DS1 and DS3 Maintenance tester in California. DS1 and DS3 are currently the backbone of the telco system in this country for cell sites, sales, industry, you name it.
I still hold by my claim if the legions of Field Techs (what everybody use to call Installers, or Repair Techs) were not able to service the infrastructure, most of it would collapse within a year.
This is if No servicing were to occur. I agree, this not how I believe things will unravel in the near future. With a shortage of fuel government will ration. Soccer Moms in SUV’s you’re screwed, learn to walk, or get a Bike!
I believe Farming, Utilities (Water, Power, and Telco), Military/Police, and Fire, will initially get all they need. But this cannot go on forever as anyone who is reading this knows.
The point I was making is the infrastructure will break down though lack of maintenance long before the generators or telco central offices are cut off from power. Maintenance will be deferred to the point where one day things go down, and stay down.
Skeptical scrutiny in both Science and Religion is the means by which deep thoughts are winnowed from deep nonsense-Carl Sagan