by GoIllini » Sat 14 Oct 2006, 03:53:58
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Dreamtwister', 'N')onsense, they would play manipulative little games to try and drive out the weakest investing hands, grabbing up as much wealth for themselves as possible before the whole economy goes right off the cliff.
Dreamtwister,
Few traders would consider taking a position against where they think the market is trending as a wise move. Yes, there may be some, but "driving out the weakest hands" isn't how the aggregate of the various professional traders operates, from my experience. In reality, professional traders make money by keeping the market efficient and tied to various data about where it's heading.
Additionally, I've never heard of a panic that lasted more than a day or two, let alone several years. My understanding is that panics happen because investors make poor-quality decisions and quickly buy or sell out of fear. If investors have a few nights to sleep on it, they generally make better decisions. That's why two months of low oil prices isn't a panic; it's something that reflects market fundamentals.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'O')h wait, that's exactly what they are doing.
The only reason the economy hasn't crashed already is precisely because there are so few people "in the know". People like your bankers and oil traders represent a very small percentage of the population (well under the 1% being discussed here), and they are using that knowledge to drive all of their weaker competition off of the trading floor.
Regardless of the percentage of the population they represent, I believe that they represent at least some two-figure percentage of the collective ability to move the market out there; perhaps more. There's no way they could keep oil prices this low for this long. Additionally, the fact that low oil prices are being driven by a buildup of inventory suggests that recent price drops have been driven by S&D fundamentals, not market manipulation or speculation.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'W')hen someone like Buffett dumps a million oz of silver onto the market,
at the exchange knows it. What does he care if he loses a million dollars, when his sell triggers a panic sell and drives the price lower? The smaller traders get squeezed out, and he comes right back in and buys all of his silver back (and everyone else's) at a discount.