by jdmartin » Wed 28 Sep 2005, 00:11:20
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Monk', '
')
Why would he build a contingency savings when he can pay down his credit card debt? So he would have a savings investment making 2-3% per year and a credit card debt costing him 18% per year.
He should pay off his credit cards. If something happens to his job, he's got the credit cards as a "contingency" source of funds.
Well, several reasons that have nothing to do with 2-3% vs. 18%:
1. Many credit cards will not let you use their card to make a payment on another card. So the idea of using the credit cards as a contingency source won't work for long. What happens when you need to make the payment on the card OR pay the electric bill?
2. As soon as you are late on a credit card payment, instead of 18% now you're up to 30%. Miss a payment or two and now you can't use the credit card at all because you're cut off. If you've got 5k set aside and need 10k, well you probably can get by making the minimum payment. If you have nothing set aside and need 10k you're probably not gonna make it.
3. If things got bad enough to the point that 5k was only enough money to cover food and the mortgage, you
could say piss on everything else and go into bankruptcy. You can place that 5k towards your mortgage, or Vegas, or whatever.
4. He's not "building" a contingency in this case, since he's already got 5k set aside. So it is not as if he's neglecting credit card debt to put hordes of money aside. A reasonable plan is to do both to the best of your ability.
Depending solely on credit cards as your backup plan with no savings is a dumb idea. Not having any money set aside to deal with emergencies is one of the biggest reasons people get into debt and can never get out.
Now, if the guy had no mortgage, and 5k could pay off all debts, I would say go for it, and quickly save back enough money to cover living expenses. But since it doesn't sound like the guy's gonna walk scott-free after paying his 5k, it's not a good idea.
There are other variables that go into the picture that we never discussed - i.e., how fast can he save up living expenses again - 6 months or 6 years, for example - that could change it somewhat. No one who has debt should walk around with zero dollars saved for an emergency. I agree, being debt-free feels marvelous, but financial sense is a holistic picture, for which most people a job and it's steady income is a huge part of that picture.
After fueling up their cars, Twyman says they bowed their heads and asked God for cheaper gas.There was no immediate answer, but he says other motorists joined in and the service station owner didn't run them off.