by richardmmm » Tue 30 Aug 2005, 12:45:34
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Ming', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'R')ichard also seemed to make a huge deal that if we had all invested our life savings in shorting oil at 9 am, by noon we could have made a lot of money. True. In hindsight. Let's see what the price does in the next two weeks and see if he was really "right" or just got lucky in the very short term.
Yes, but not even that!
$70.80 was only achieved just after opening of trade, on Sunday, well before regular (Monday) trading in NYMEX pit. Almost no one could have traded at that price.
Then he includes a pyramiding scheme, reinvesting all the intermediate profit up to the limit of the margin requirements. A single up tick during the drop (and there where several moments of up movement on prices) would have closed all the open positions.
He uses the absolute maximum and absolute minimum of the day to calculate “his” profits…
And he writes about it after that drop in prices has occurred, so he was not even right on the short term, he merely used a past movement to speculate on possible maximum gains…
Maybe you can help me out here because I am confused.
Is the purpose of an online forum to have some intelligent discussion, or is the purpose of it for bigoted and petty minded people to entertain themselves with slandering and writing off just about anything and everything that is posted ?
I am not going to start posting exact details of my trades any more than I am going to mail you a stool sample. I was short oil and gas on friday and i shorted more on sunday night / monday. NYMEX has a night market called Access which traded 250,000 units before the open so your statement about no one being able to trade it is based on shear ignorance and bigotry. Thousands of contracts also traded on the QM mini nymex oil which was open from 7pm Sunday EST.
I have been trading the markets full time for nearly 5 years. It pays my bills, computers, food, mortgages etc. How about you Mr. expert ? how long have you been trading for ?
London markets were closed Monday for a holiday. Incase you didn't know the IPE is a huge electronic oil / energy futures exchange with higher volumes than NYMEX. Now that has come online obviously the same little hysterical dance has to go on with prices running to silly levels and dropping back down again.
If your life savings amount to only $50,000 then you have no business discussing oil futures trading or frankly trading of any kind at all.
The point I was trying to bring out was that his is going to be a major top out in the energy markets and we'll see crude back to $50 soon enough.
It's the same with stocks, google brings out record earning and you'd expect prices to run, instead they drop like a rock as people take profits, expectations already being built into the market.
Same with oil, bad news has already been built into the prices, the run from $50-67 was basically an anticipation of supply disruptions. Oil investories consitently increased there was no reason for the run, except for speculation on supply disruptions. Now the disruptions have arrived we can expect to see prices topping out.
This is a basic tenet of trading any market. I don't expect to get attacked and slandered for pointing out something that is writen in even the most basic trading books.
Sure there could be a super spike to $80+, somehow I don't think there will be and even if there is it will collapse quickly.
I can always be wrong, the future might laugh in my face, but histroy shows major tops at these times.
For example there was an $8 drop after all the bad news of Ivan was out of the way.
For example the day troops started invading Iraq, inspite of potential chemical and biological warefare which could have completely cut off access to oil fields, oil dropped like a stone, because the price was already built in.
Buy on rumor sell on news, it's a simple trading strategy.
There was speculation that the hurricane would hit oil fields. Once it hit them there was a sell off.
Now there is speculation about the damage.
As the damage reports come out there will be a sell off.
It's simple for any bonehead to understand if they want to.