by Graeme » Tue 04 Feb 2014, 16:08:52
Welcome to PO.com!
Is hydrogen fuel making a comeback?
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'H')ydrogen is now back on the agenda, for three main reasons.
First, hydrogen fuel cell vehicles can still provide a much greater range than battery electric vehicles, with a refuelling time of less than five minutes compared to six to eight hours for batteries.
Second, the costs of producing hydrogen from renewables by water electrolysis, and of fuel cells, have fallen over the past decade as dramatically as that for solar panels. For example, the high-volume production cost of fuel cells fell from $275 per kilowatt in 2002 to only $51 per kilowatt.
Third, we now understand that there are many severe constraints on biofuel production. These include competition with food production, and the use of water, land, and fertilisers.
reneweconomyHyundai On Hydrogen Fuel-Cell Vehicles: Critiquing Its Claims$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'T')he piece summarizes those issues in three statements:
Grid-powered cars have lower wells-to-wheels greenhouse-gas emission than hydrogen-fueled cars;
The cost of hydrogen infrastructure poses a fundamental barrier to widespread deployment of hydrogen vehicles; and
Slow charging of plug-in cars is offset by the convenience of overnight home charging, impossible for hydrogen cars.
We think that's a fair summary of the main arguments.
New UC-Irvine study
Addressing the wells-to-wheels carbon footprint issue, the piece notes that a recent analysis by the Advanced Power and Energy Program, at the University of California at Irvine shows essentially equivalent greenhouse-gas emissions for hydrogen and battery vehicles when accounting for all inputs, including "feedstock, production, transmission and consumption."
Battery-powered vehicles have "a small advantage in California based on the cleaner grid here, while [fuel-cell vehicles have] a small advantage on a national basis," she continues.