by Outcast_Searcher » Sun 13 May 2012, 12:55:40
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('SeaGypsy', 'I') don't know what rock dinternet has been hiding under, as I have been all over Australia many times and much of it recently: there are homeless shelters in every capital city and in most large country towns. They are usually run by church based charity organizations with a few start up NGO secularist business entrants in the big capitals/ Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane. These places are very complex businesses which rely on complex government grant procedures to get up. Part of the application process is proving how your plan can get people out of the homelessness trap. Staffing them is a nightmare, costs are huge, if any profit is left it might be as much as a wage.
+1
I second that, for America. I have a VERY smart liberal friend who wanted to pitch me his favorite charity. Once I get things lined up to be able to help, I ask him about it. It's a local homeless shelter with government mandates/rules/complexity as SeaGypsy describes (this is a non-profit though).
I'm happy to help -- at least with him running it I know the money won't be stolen or directly misused and it will "help" some people. OTOH I have no illusions that it will "change the lives" of a meaningful amount of homeless people, etc.
I'd actually prefer to see more government education programs which help newly unemployed people get meaningful skill retraining -- in exchange for an ironclad (wage garnishment if necessary) agreement to pay for the training over time. That way it's not a complete handout, and it might actually do some good. If folks like me wanted to contribute to improve the quality or lower the payback costs -- so much the better.
But the comments that Pops made earlier on this thread about "people are different" is absolutely correct. Not citing any "fault" -- motivations, skill levels, intelligence, ability to conform, health, etc. all play a role. Some of these things can be controlled by self discipline, some can't. I suspect it is VERY hard to tell malingering from genuine suffering/problems for a given individual (re: our differences).
And as I recall someone else said on this thread, no matter how much help you provide, there will be people lining up to "game the system" (my words) to the extent any resources can be exhausted.
To me, the problem seems intractible, given the trend toward automation AND the seemingly constant trend for the least educated populations to massively reporduce. (Not placing blame - just citing long running statistics).
Given the track record of the perma-doomer blogs, I wouldn't bet a fast crash doomer's money on their predictions.