by aahala » Fri 28 Sep 2007, 11:09:15
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Madpaddy', 'a')ahala,
Read it and weep baby.
My apologies to you for not making my objection clearer.
I have no trouble with describing 2006 as a plateau. I think
it a fair description of the oil production data.
My objection was this sentence:
"Global oil production will plateau at less than 100m barrels per day before 2020."
You posted it this month. It's a claim about the future,
a prediction of future events, just like the predictions in the
original article of the thread.
You're the claimant. It's your responsibility to provide evidence
sufficient for acceptance, if you want us to accept it. How is
a plateau in the past prove oil will plateau again in the future
by the year 2020 and below a certain level.
We had a much longer period of flat production in the 1989-1994
period, yet production then rose. It's not specifically stated, but
I think it's fair to describe the statements in the thread and the
articles as believing once oil plateaus, oil production will never
again exceed that level.