by ReverseEngineer » Sat 22 Nov 2008, 03:57:37
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('nobodypanic', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ReverseEngineer', ' ') The system HAS to collapse.
i think you should play around w/the idea that the system
has collaps
ed.
this is just, oh i don't know, residual energy, inertia, reflex... what have you.
i'd be curious to see what you come up with.
You can't really make the case as of yet that the system HAS collapsed, because of course there is still food on the supermarket shelves, there is still gas to be had at the INCREDIBLY low price of under $3/gal up here, and of course *I* am still employed! Far as I am concerned, this business about the economy crashing is all just a myth perpetuated here on Peak Oil. "The sun will come out Tomorrow, Tomorrow, its only a Day Away!". LOL.
Its not always even so easy to argue that the system is in the PROCESS of collapse with some of the members here. You still hear bandied about terms like "market correction" for a 50% loss of value in the DJIA. Mighty big correction there. LOL. In my book as a teacher, if I have to correct 50% of your WRONG answers on a test, you FAILED. I guess Capitalism is different though. As long as somebody still has $1 left at the end of all this, Capitalism remains a going concern and said person can buy up the entire world with that last dollar!
The other arguments put forth that the system doesn't necessarily HAVE to collapse are based on the idea its possible to print your way out of the debt as long as all the debt is denominated in dollars. You might make the currency worthless, but the system would actually remain intact in some of these arguments. Some other arguments are based on the idea that since some nations are Creditors, they might in the end buy up all the devalued assets for pennies on the dollar, and turn the entire US into a Slave state to the Chinese, thus perpetuating the system in a Role Reversal. The US hits the Transgender Nation Clinic and gets a Penectomy, and the Chinese fabricate a Penis in one of their still operating Factories I guess.
Now, I have spent the last few months battling these ideas, but somehow they still persist here on Peak Oil despite my best efforts and some interminably long posts, so one has to consider the possibility I could be WRONG here. LOL. I actually can envision ways in which the system could be salvaged in some form, so I cannot in all honesty make a 100% Guarantee of total collapse of the monetary system. However, those methods don't prevent a massive dislocation in economic terms, and I would still consider such a resolution to be a collapse.
Effectively, yes the system has already collapsed, its just a nightmare of paperwork involved in getting the collapse tallied up, and its not all occuring at the same speed in all parts of the building. This is not an instantaneous drop to ground level like the World Trade Center. Its a more spread out building, a bank fails here, an auto company fails there, a Hedge Fund liquidates somewhere else, and the credit markets are locked up like a Catholic School virgin in a Chastity Belt. LOL. These are clear signs the system has collapsed already, butt he effects still are not being felt by EVERY member of the society, so far only directly by some in the path of the Tsunami at the moment.
Because we have some kind of social welfare system in place with Unemployment Insurance, folks recently put out of work aren't yet completly destitute, their benefits won't run out for a few more months unless of course the Goobermint stops sending out checks. How big a load of jobless claims and benefits can this system support at any one time? Clearly, if they just print money to pay off on the benefits, this immediately contributes in direct form to inflation of the money supply in the real economy.
Anyhow, there are so many systems in place here and so many possible schemes to keep an economy of some sort running that you really do not hit a brick wall at 500MPH. Parts of the system break down, slowing down the machine, and the Air Bag of mediation schemes softens the crash some. At this point, I don't see the supermarket shelves going empty in a year, I think its going to take more than that to grind this part of the economy to a complete halt. I think there will be nationalization of the shipping industry and trucking industry and food production industry and energy industry. Will it operate with the marvelous efficiency of Capitalism when its all run by the Goobermint? That is a tough question to answer, because Capitalism operates in times of Plenty, and the waste and excesses of the system get hidden. Socialist, Fascist and Communist solutions operate in times of resource depletion, when the objective is not making a profit, but distributing out the pain of scarcity in some kind of equitable fashion, depending on what your concept of equity is. For some, that concept of equity is distributing out the remaining resources only to a few people and leaving the rest to twist in the wind. That is Fascism. Communism attempts to distribute out the remaining resources to the many. I don't think Democratic Socialism of the Swedish model really persists in this environment, any more than Capitalism can work in such an environment. You have to have a surplus for such a socialist system to operate, just as you need a surplus for Capitalism to operate.
Anyhow, to return to the point of the OP and get a little less abstract here, what you have worldwide is an inequitable distribution of resources, symbolized in the monetary system by excess Capital in some countries, and an excess of debt in others. Because the system is so far out of balance, Creditor nations are being asked to move Capital to debtor nations to keep the flow of money moving round here. If they DON'T do that, they are screwed because their goods won't be bought, and to my mind at least the idea that say the Chinese could plug the gap through internal demand is preposterous, but others here seem to think such a thing is possible. The Saudis are clearly in the deep doo doo, because ALL they have is Oil, and if the economic machine falls apart too rapidly, there is no market for their oil and they will STARVE. So I really could see the Saudis coughing up money here or "Oil Credits", basically shipping Oil to the US for food and a promise to pay something later. On the macro scale, this could keep the system moving along for at least a couple of year IMHO.
Has it collapsed? It all depends how you define what collapse IS. If collapse is a descent into African level poverty or Mad Max Zombie Wars, no we are not there yet. If you define collapse as a Stock Market and Trade system floundering and pissing out value faster than a J6P pisses out Beer after consuming a Case or two, we passed that point a while back. How long it takes for the latter form of collapse to translate to the former definition is an open question which NOBODY on Peak Oil can answer with any authority.
Reverse Engineer