Donate Bitcoin

Donate Paypal


PeakOil is You

PeakOil is You

Time to build a new civilization

What's on your mind?
General interest discussions, not necessarily related to depletion.

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby galacticsurfer » Thu 30 Oct 2008, 16:27:20

Link
The Complete Works Of Chuang Tzu Translated by Burton Watson

1 : Free and Easy Wandering
2 : Discussion on Making All Things Equal
3 : The Secret of Caring for Life
4 : In the World of Men
5 : The Sign of Virtue Complete
6 : The Great and Venerable Teacher
7 : Fit for Emperors and Kings
8 : Webbed Toes
9 : Horses' Hoofs
10 : Riffling Trunks
11 : Let It Be, Leave It Alone
12 : Heaven and Earth
13 : The Way of Heaven
14 : The Turning of Heaven
15 : Constrained in Will
16 : Mending the Inborn Nature
17 : Autumn Floods
18 : Perfect Happiness
19 : Mastering Life
20 : The Mountain Tree
21 : T'ien Tzu-fang
22 : Knowledge Wandered North
23 : Keng-sang C'hu
24 : Hsu Wu-kei
25 : Tse-yang
26 : External Things
27 : Inputed Words
28 : Giving Away a Throne
29 : Robber Chih
30 : Discoursing on Swords
31 : The Old Fishermman
32 : Lieh Yu-k'ou
33 : The World
"The horror, the horror"
User avatar
galacticsurfer
Coal
Coal
 
Posts: 449
Joined: Wed 09 Nov 2005, 04:00:00

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby TWilliam » Thu 30 Oct 2008, 16:36:39

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ReverseEngineer', 'U')nlike Physical Traits, Philosophy does not need to be passed from one generation to the next by biological reproduction. It can be passed from one individual to the next through IDEAS, and it can perpetuate itself through generations, really it can perpetuate itself for as long as there are people around to talk to and discuss ideas.

You are right to a degree I believe, RE. While yes, ideas do not pass on genetically, I think one's ability to entertain certain ideas is to at least some extent impacted by one's genetics. I think it's been pretty well established by now that there are some genetic factors involved in overall intelligence, which I suspect has some bearing on what one does (if anything) with the knowledge and experience gained throughout life.

It's kind of like a computer. While one can write fantastic and complex code, there are limits imposed by the hardware regarding to what extent said code functions. You're not likely to get Windows Vista running on an old 386 with 256 Megs of RAM, for example. Similarly, I think the ability to 'think deeply' about certain things is more than simply a function of training (programming)...

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('katkinkate', 'I')t's more than just intelligence, it's maturity. The mature socialised adult human, has learned the consequences of their own actions, has taken reponsibility for themselves and recognises the value of constraining their own wants, in order to share with the greater community and is satisfied with this. They no longer feel the competitive drive to own as much as possible, even at the expense of others, even if those others are other species.

Western civilisation is at the mental level of the adolescent, "I want everything I want, now and even more tomorrow! And don't tell me how to live my life!"

Indeed. And the culture's level of maturity has an exceedingly strong impact upon the level of individual maturity one is able to attain, which I think also plays a role in reducing the overall number of 'excessively' intelligent people out there, since they tend to be socially ostracized...
"It means buckle your seatbelt, Dorothy, because Kansas? Is goin' bye-bye... "
User avatar
TWilliam
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 2591
Joined: Sun 28 Nov 2004, 04:00:00

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby Cid_Yama » Thu 30 Oct 2008, 16:50:40

Like I said, you are better off with <b>The Tao of Pooh</b> <i>by Benjamin Hoff</i>.

English translation and western ears do not do Chuang Tzu justice.

Translations do not convey the metaphors known as common knowledge within a culture. The <i>meaning</i> is lost.

There was a Star Trek: Next Generation episode that addressed this when they encountered a species that spoke only in metaphors.

"Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra" is meaningless unless you already know the story of Darmok and Jalad.

If everyone in your culture knows the story of Darmok and Jalad, everyone knows what you refer to.

Another culture, on the other hand, who are unfamiliar with Darmok and Jalad, won't understand the meaning.

It is amazing how much more is conveyed by the metaphors we speak than by the words.

Tao of Pooh will give you the gist, the meaning, the essence. Once you have that you can then go on to Chinese Taoist writings with some sense of comprehension. (By the way, the above translations of Chuang Tzu are atrocious.)

Try this site.
http://www.stillness.com/tao/index.html
"For my part, whatever anguish of spirit it may cost, I am willing to know the whole truth; to know the worst and provide for it." - Patrick Henry

The level of injustice and wrong you endure is directly determined by how much you quietly submit to. Even to the point of extinction.
User avatar
Cid_Yama
Light Sweet Crude
Light Sweet Crude
 
Posts: 7169
Joined: Sun 27 May 2007, 03:00:00
Location: The Post Peak Oil Historian

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby TWilliam » Thu 30 Oct 2008, 23:24:00

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Cid_Yama', 'L')ike I said, you are better off with <b>The Tao of Pooh</b> <i>by Benjamin Hoff</i>.

English translation and western ears do not do Chuang Tzu justice.

Translations do not convey the metaphors known as common knowledge within a culture. The <i>meaning</i> is lost.

There was a Star Trek: Next Generation episode that addressed this when they encountered a species that spoke only in metaphors.

"Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra" is meaningless unless you already know the story of Darmok and Jalad.

If everyone in your culture knows the story of Darmok and Jalad, everyone knows what you refer to.

Another culture, on the other hand, who are unfamiliar with Darmok and Jalad, won't understand the meaning.

It is amazing how much more is conveyed by the metaphors we speak than by the words.

Tao of Pooh will give you the gist, the meaning, the essence. Once you have that you can then go on to Chinese Taoist writings with some sense of comprehension. (By the way, the above translations of Chuang Tzu are atrocious.)

Try this site.
http://www.stillness.com/tao/index.html

I remember that episode; it illustrated the difficulties of translation between cultures quite well I thought.

Same issue exists when looking at any 'sacred' writings. One example that comes to mind involves the biblical admonition about 'cutting off thine hand if it offend thee'. Often taken by certain fundamentalist sects literally, but if you ask those few remaining people that speak Aramaic, you discover that the colloquialism that translates as such is still in use today, and is never in it's native context taken literally. It's kind of like telling someone to 'stick it up their @ss' in western vernacular. Few, if any of us, would take it literally...
"It means buckle your seatbelt, Dorothy, because Kansas? Is goin' bye-bye... "
User avatar
TWilliam
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 2591
Joined: Sun 28 Nov 2004, 04:00:00

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby ReverseEngineer » Fri 31 Oct 2008, 03:07:14

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('mos6507', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('katkinkate', 'W')estern civilisation is at the mental level of the adolescent, "I want everything I want, now and even more tomorrow! And don't tell me how to live my life!"
Exactly. I think the term for this is decadence, the attribute normally associated with a civilization on the decline (last days of Rome as a cliche' comparison).
This economic downturn is going to be a dose of good medicine. I just hate that the responsible people have to suffer along with the spoiled brats.

You might consider making analogies to the collapse of the Roman Empire "cliche", but it is the best example extant we have with a decent amount of written history behind it. Prior civilization collapses have thin history behind them, not really that much is known about the Babylonians for instance besides what is written in the Bible, and stuff from that period was mostly passed down as Oral History prior to the invention of writing.

Besides the Currency and Military parallels already discussed in a few other threads here, "Decadence" or "Moral Corruption" (depending on how you like to phrase this concept), quite clearly the corruption you see evident in current society mirrors the corruption of Rome in its dying days. Greed, Gluttony, Sexual Perversion, all are present now in at least as much frequency as in the final days of the Roman Empire.

It all comes down to a debasement of the Human Spirit in favor of the Pursuit of Wealth. It is sad that regardless of your innocence in the moral corruption of the society as a whole that ALL suffer because of this, not just those who are responsible. Society as it grows however always holds in it the seeds of moral corruption, and as long as you countenance it you are yourself morally culpable for that. Keeping an OP system on your computer free of Bugs is a tedious task, every day really you have to run the anti-viral software and purge the viruses that could infect and overwhelm your computer. You might not be guilty, but because you were not effective in erradicating the corruption, you become corrupt, and your computer is taken offline also.

It has been our collective mistake as a society NOT to purge the Greedy out of it and not to understand that we are all the children of Mother Nature and to be good stewards of the collective resource of our planet which is our home. Nobody is innocent here, and so we all pay the price now for the mistakes made.

Some are more Guilty than Others though. The less you care about the plight of others, the more guilty you are. The more money you have, the more guilty you are. If you make the choice to live at the expense of others rather than do your best to help others, you are more guilty than others. You will Burn in Everlating Torment in the Fires of Hell because of it.

Do what you can to help your community. Be a good steward of the resources of Mother Earth, at whose breast you suckle your life from. You will be rewarded for this by the Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven. No mortgage, no debt attached. It is the true Wealth you accumulate through the course of your life.

Reverse Engineer
User avatar
ReverseEngineer
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 3352
Joined: Wed 16 Jul 2008, 03:00:00
Top

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby ReverseEngineer » Fri 31 Oct 2008, 05:24:41

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Cid_Yama', 'T')here was a Star Trek: Next Generation episode that addressed this when they encountered a species that spoke only in metaphors. "Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra" is meaningless unless you already know the story of Darmok and Jalad.

I write in metaphor all the time, this subject is one very near and dear to my heart.

"Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra" is not meaningless, even if you do not know the story. The mere fact that DJT is referenced tells you something about the mindset of the person referencing the idiom. It tells you that concepts are referred to idiomatically, and that you have to think deeper than just the text which you read. You can remain confused or you can seek to understand.

All fundamental concepts are housed idiomatically when language is applied, a good portion of the aguments here defending various "isms" are contained in presuppositions regarding how Capitalism was pursued in the Western world and how Communism was pursued in Russia and China, but of course NONE of these examples in a true sense represent any of the"isms".

Read any Religious tome, from the Bible to the Bhagavit Gita, its all housed in idiom. You certainly cannot understand Revelations by a straight reading of the text. Does this mean however that Revelations is without meaning? Perhaps, but I would not count on that, and so I would seek to read for meaning and analyse the subtext.

It has been my experience that when you dissect any argument, when you confront any philosophy, the truth lies not in what is answered, but in what is NOT answered. Those here who defend particular "-isms" will answer what they CAN answer, they will ignore what they CANNOT answer. Or they will demean the poster and obfuscate the questions of importance with tangents that drive the discussion off the fundamental questions they cannot answer.

Read the subtext. Seek to understand not what was said, but what was left unsaid or ignored. Look for the HOLES, the Empty Spaces in an argument. They are ALWAYS there. Once identified, HAMMER DOWN on them. Force the person who espouses a viewpoint to deal with what he or she has IGNORED. Just be prepared for the fact that if you do this, you will not make too many friends. LOL. In an argument though, making friends is not what is really important. Elucidating the TRUTH is what is important. It can be done. More often by understanding what is NOT said than what IS said.

Reverse Engineer
User avatar
ReverseEngineer
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 3352
Joined: Wed 16 Jul 2008, 03:00:00
Top

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby kakkerlak » Sun 02 Nov 2008, 11:47:41

Before it's even possible to think about building a new world, a better world, the old world/civilization has to disappear first. It is not longer possible to change the current way of thinking and the current way of doing things anymore. The system/world is not under our control anymore, we're just part of it.

Our minds are polluted and corruption is dripping into our souls every day, if we want it or not. Everything we have and everything we do has consequences. For every cookie we eat, for every time we flush the toilet, something beautiful is destroyed, without us even knowing about it. We don't even have a choice anymore; We need to eat, we need to go to the toilet, we need a roof above us. Many many more people need the exact same thing and that's just not possible; the Earth can't support that.

Our current civilization and everything associated with it is nothing less then a monster, a beautiful monster in some cases. Think about it; If we're hungry we can eat as much as we want, if we want knowledge we can sit behind our computers and simply download it, If we want to communicate, we just have to push a few buttons on our mobile phones. It's incredible. It is awesome. It's wonderful. And at the same time all those things have consequences for other people and other living things. At the same time it is horrifying, terrible, maybe even evil.

Every phone call, every hour on the internet, every minute in a car, every sandwich we eat. Everything we do has direct or indirect consequences for others. But we don't have a choice. Not a real choice. Not anymore.

Our civilization can't be fixed. We can't solve the problems we're facing. We can't solve overpopulation or the damage done to the environment. We can try but we inevitably fail at it. It's not under our control anymore.

History is not on our side either. Many things that happen now are the result of things that happened a long time ago. To be more accurate, everything that happens is the result of history. Reaction follows on action. Throw a ball against a wall and it will bounce back at you.

We have polluted the earth and we have allowed our species to breed like rabbits to get to a population of almost 7 billion. We did that and nobody else. We fight wars, we kill other people, we even kill other species. Sometimes we do these things without us even knowing about it.

However we turn, bend or twist this around. Whatever excuses we try to use to justify our behaviour. The truth will not change. We're responsible. We're responsible for our actions and blaming someone or something else is just stupid, foolish and futile.

We, humans, have build the current world situation. We made some good choices and we made some bad choices. Sometimes we didn't make a choice at all. The world as it is now is the result, the result of thousands of years of history. The result of many many choices.

Before we can even think about making a better world. Before we can make a new beginning, the old has to disappear first.

Wise man

Homo sapiens means "wise human". If we want to have a better world then we have to behave like "wise humans", using wisdom, by being wise. At this very moment we're still behaving like monkeys. Exactly like monkeys. A "wise man" is able to control him/her self. A monkey can't do that.

You can make a monkey do everything just by giving it a few bananas. The same applies to humans (at the moment). How much does it take to make you do something bad? To corrupt your mind? What's your price? How many bananas do i have to feed you?

It's not only our actions we have to learn to control. We also have to learn to control our thoughts. Hate, jealously, revenge, greed, anger, fear etc. are all thoughts/feelings with the power to corrupt us. Giving into one of these thoughts will inevitably result in some kind of suffering, into un-happiness. Anytime someone allows these thoughts for too long will make the world a tiny little bit worse.

If we want a better world we have to improve ourselves. Enlightenment is the goal here, love is the tool. We have to think about our own thoughts, analyze them and if necessary correct them.

I have still faith in humanity. I still believe we can make the world a better place, in time. I still believe humanity is able to take the path to enlightenment. But not before we have suffered the consequences from past and present actions. The ball will always bounce back when you throw it against a wall.

We are children, playing with fire

If you place your hand in fire you end up with a burned hand and that will hurt. We have to learn from that. We have to learn that placing our hands in fire is not a good idea. We have to learn to not do it anymore or else we will hurt ourselves again and again and again.

We have thousands of years of history to learn from. We made every mistake we can make, multiple times. We also have seen multiple examples of how we should behave, how we should think, how we should act. It is time to learn from it.

This is our real challenge. This is our real problem. We!

Have fun!
Roach
As an obsessive perfectionist it is not unusual for me to spend an hour writing and re-writing a single sentence. When abandoning perfection i ask you to judge me on my ideas, not on my words.
User avatar
kakkerlak
Peat
Peat
 
Posts: 88
Joined: Fri 18 Jan 2008, 04:00:00
Location: The Netherlands

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby dunewalker » Sun 02 Nov 2008, 12:16:51

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('kakkerlak', '.')..Homo sapiens means "wise human". If we want to have a better world then we have to behave like "wise humans", using wisdom, by being wise. At this very moment we're still behaving like monkeys. Exactly like monkeys. A "wise man" is able to control him/her self. A monkey can't do that.

I think this is backwards. Humans are set apart from all other species by their "wisdom", even in the Latin nomenclature. I would argue that we are the only species that has lost its innate wisdom of survival. Another term for this is "instinct". We no longer are able to instinctively do "the right thing" for the survival of the species. I recently re-read "The Ohlone Way" by Malcolm Margolin and "Ishi" by Theodora Kroeber -- both describe the original human inhabitants of California and their cultures, which sustained them for thousands of years by understanding their relationship to and dependence on, their ecosystems. These civilizations were systematically annihilated by Christian-based cultures importing greed and ignorance of the natural world.
"Wilderness is another civilization apart from our own." - H.D. Thoreau
User avatar
dunewalker
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1253
Joined: Thu 30 Jun 2005, 03:00:00
Location: northern California
Top

Re: Time to build a new civilization

Unread postby ReverseEngineer » Sun 02 Nov 2008, 12:28:46

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('kakkerlak', 'W')e have thousands of years of history to learn from. We made every mistake we can make, multiple times. We also have seen multiple examples of how we should behave, how we should think, how we should act. It is time to learn from it.

A very well written post, I agree with almost all of it. There is no doubt that before we can rebuild here, the edifice we have constructed has to be destroyed completely. The question would be in this case whether we have already done such a good job of destroying the edfice that is the Earth that it will no longer support human life at all?

In the event that is not the case and humanity does emerge out from beyond the Zero Point, I would take issue with one thing in your post, the assertion we "have made every mistake we can make". I don't think so. As long as there are human beings, they will find new mistakes to make. As long as the mistakes aren't fatal, that's OK. In this case, it appears they may be fatal.
Reverse Engineer
User avatar
ReverseEngineer
Intermediate Crude
Intermediate Crude
 
Posts: 3352
Joined: Wed 16 Jul 2008, 03:00:00
Top

Previous

Return to Open Topic Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests

cron