by AgentR » Sat 20 Sep 2008, 21:54:56
Just finished watching it and did have a few critiques...
Early in the series, he discusses money supply, compounding, and exponential functions; and makes a point that money supply is ruled by these same exponential functions. I feel this is misleading in that while past data does fit an exponential curve; future performance is dictictated STRICTLY by choices made by people who can arbitrarily shut it down, or create a positive discontinuity by a mass dump of hard currency directly to the system.
Next, an assumption that if a choice between prosperity and growth is to be made; the unanimous choice is/shoudlbe prosperity; but I think that is also inaccurate. Some would choose growth even at the expense of prosperity.
Late in the series he discusses EROEI principles; beginning with an absolute example (income vs tax); but then shifts to a ratio based discussion. This looks good on a graph of course, but fudges the reality that if you can find a big enough pool of X, wasting 98% of it to get 2% gain, can give you an absolutely huge amount of X to be spent.
Other than that though, its well worth listening to; and I'm somone who will almost never watch a youtube or anything else 3rd party posted here.
Yes, we are. As we are.
And so shall we remain; Until the end.