I routinely use hypermiling techniques in my driving and have been doing the engine-off coasting for the better part of a year. And so far I have had to nail the throttle in an emergency a grand total of
ZERO times. As a matter of fact, the only times I have ever had to use the throttle to rescue myself from any driving condition have been when I was exceeding safe driving speeds to a significant degree (while racing or on snow or ice). So that emergency throttle argument is just a ridiculous one statistically, and an impractical one in reality because the vast majority of the driving public wouldn't know what to do with it anyway. So let's just throw that silly argument aside ok?
Ok, with 'emergency throttle' put to bed, one cannot ignore the other issues with braking and steering. Both can be serious issues if you don't know what to expect without power or vacuum assist. In other words, if you can't comfortably steer or stop your vehicle without the assistance of the vacuum booster or power steering, for the love of fuel addiction, DON'T FREAKIN' DO IT! Obviously this includes anybody who's steering locks with the ingition in the accessory power position as well!
What I have found however is the majority of my engine off coasting can in fact be done in gear. (For vehicles with fuel injection and manual transmissions only of course.) Left in 5th, the additional drag of turning the motor is miniscule, yet I still save considerably on fuel consumption without sacrificing either my power steering or vacuum assist since the motor continues to both turn the steering pump and generate vacuum. This technique has the added benefit of reducing wear on restarts, presuming they are done before coasting below the threshold speed for doing that. It also skirts the legality issue of coasting in neutral. (To my knowledge there are no laws that state the motor has to be running at all times.)
All it takes to refire the motor is a quick flick of the key back on - something that can arguably done more quickly than say trying to put the transmission back into a useable gear.
I won't deny that this extra step to refire the motor adds delay and potential risk, however one should not rule out the reality that most people using this technique are probably looking much further down the road than the average driver anyway. So to that I say 'whatever'.
Drive safe.
