by mkwin » Thu 20 Mar 2008, 08:04:30
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'A')fter that, if you still feel like it, get back to insisting that financial speculation is not the main driver for short-term price movements of the crude oil prices.
(But dont insist on that before checking the proof that has already been presented to you!)
I'll take that bet!
Although I am sure there are small price swings because of speculators, their impact on the market overall is still relatively small. Traders acting on behalf of commercial entities will react to economic news as well. This may be the point you are making as well but I just wanted to be clear
the bull market in oil is not caused by speculators.
The table you posted fails to show the overall positions of both Commercial (oil companies and refiners) and Non-commercial (Speculators). Commercial market particpants clearly dominate the market. Speculators also have lots of short positions. The percentage of the net postive long position for speculators to total contracts has only increased by 2% since the price of oil has gone up $40. Are we to believe the extra demand for 2% worth of long positions has caused the oil price to almost double. I don't think so.
Commitments May 1st 2007 : Oil Price approx $64
Non-Commercial Long = 195,239
Non-Commercial Short = 129,116
Net Non-COM Position = 66,123
% of Speculators long = 60%
Commercial Long = 830,557
Commercial Short = 890,444
Net COM position = -59,887
% of Net NON-COM position to open Interest = 4.9%
% of Commercial Short Positions to total positions = 66.36%
Commitments March 4th 2008 : Oil Price approx $102.5
Non-Commercial Long = 258,292
Non-Commercial Short = 159,390
Net Non-COM Position = 99,539
% of Speculators Long = 61.8%
Commercial Long = 879,674
Commercial Short = 982,509
Net COM position = -102,835
% of Net NON-COM position to open Interest = 6.8%
% of Commecial Short Positions to Total Contracts = 67.7%
Yes the level of speculation has increased both on the long and short side, but so has the volume of commercial users.
JD and co will have us believe that speculation is the key to the bull markets in commodities and oil but the decline in the value of the dollar and the industrialisation of Asia are far bigger drivers. Even in the oil market, speculators are out numbered 4 to 1 and even then, only 60% are long.