by BlisteredWhippet » Thu 31 Jan 2008, 17:52:32
I defy you to MAKE DIESEL YOURSELF.
How are you going to do it? Biodiesel? Where are you going to make Methanol? Sodium Hydroxide? What kind of inputs is your crop of rapeseed or Canola going to consume? What ecological effects does your mini-industrial Agriculture have? How many "miles per acre" so you can squirt by, wasting 70% of your energy? What energy is used harvesting your crop? Cost of purifying your biodiesel feedstocks?
What this really boils down to, in my mind, is the difference in difficulty between alcohol distillation and Biodiesel reaction. The latter is far more intensive and costly. As for complexity of an engine system between SI and compression, I wouldn't say the difference is significant.
As for systemic efficiency, diesel isn't a better fuel for most applications. Thats why its not used in motorcycles and cars. The SI engine is more reliable, to my mind, and versatile. For personal use, the whole concept of efficiency is more tied to my ability to produce it, not whether my implement or vehicle is a few percentage points here or there.
The reason gasoline isn't used in heavy machinery or transport is that it doesn't have the higher BTU content of diesel, that is needed to supply the raw power for moving heavy objects. And when diesel is used for those applications, its dumped into the engine by the barrel, and efficiency one way or the other is talking about large volumes of fuel.
Once the fuel situation gets dire, there is not going to be domestic diesel for sale for your personal automobile. And when civilization collapses, no one is going to be making biodiesel. Its a much better bet, therefore, for SI, because Joe Blow was making ethanol since the 1700s.
Last edited by
BlisteredWhippet on Thu 31 Jan 2008, 23:56:16, edited 2 times in total.