by Euric » Tue 28 Dec 2004, 13:53:16
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Kingcoal', 'E')uric, you keep saying that nothing is made in America, yet I keep hearing about European companies that want to move production here, Volvo being the latest. Also, from what I can see, US manufacturing is in about the same state as in Europe. Does Nokia make it's phones in Europe? Does Braun make it's coffee makers in Europe? How is European industry in better shape than America's? Europe's steel industry is subsidized, as is it's aerospace industry. All that comes out of the EU's collective treasuries.
Talk is cheap. When these companies actually move then we will cross that bridge and wonder what effect, if any, it will have. Keep in mind, if Volvo does come, they will follow the Pattern of BMW and open in the non-union south, with a minimum of workers as most of their processes will be automated. In Europe, it is still not legal in some countries to close down a factory and just move the work elsewhere. A business may close if it isn't doing well, which is not the same thing. Companies may expand and do so in a cheap labour market, and that is what you may be observing.
Subsidising works in the EU because the money comes from surpluses, not from the air. The US can't subsidise businesses unless it has real money to do it with. It can borrow, float bonds, but that just adds more to the deficit.
But in the US it is completely legal to close a factory and move it entirely to a new location with out any concern for the welfare of the former workers.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'E')urope makes big, high margin stuff like cars, heavy machinery, etc. Guess what, so does America. Not much gets exported because the demand in America eats it all up. In Europe, same thing; why buy a Caterpillar earthmover when you can have one from Volvo. Oh yeah, I forgot, Volvo is talking about making them in America!
If it is all the same thing, they why does the US run up such high deficits and the EU does not? The US doesn't really have an export attitude when it come to manufacturing. Thus when sales are down, they just lay off and wait for the bust cycle to end.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'T')o sum up, Europe has exported its low margin manufacturing to Asia just as America has. The whole world has become accustomed to cheap imports from Asia. In America, we are hip deep in them. Asia, Inc., has found out that if it's products go over a price level, demand drops way off. We buy a lot of cheap stuff from Asia because, well, it's cheap!