Donate Bitcoin

Donate Paypal


PeakOil is You

PeakOil is You

Education Level Poll

What's on your mind?
General interest discussions, not necessarily related to depletion.

Your Highest Level of Academic Achievement:

Currently in high school
2
No votes
Currently in college
6
No votes
high school diploma
3
No votes
some college but no degree
16
No votes
bachelor's degree
19
No votes
graduate degree of any kind (MBA, PhD, law degree, etc.)
24
No votes
other
2
No votes
 
Total votes : 72

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby Tyler_JC » Sat 07 Oct 2006, 22:27:31

NEOPO, the doomers stay here because this forum is entertaining and informative.

Other doomers stay here because they want to teach others about PO and perhaps learn more about the issue themselves. Sometimes they are trying to learn about the newest alternative energy scheme in order to shut it down.

This website does provide a wealth of resources for people who want to know about almost anything.
"www.peakoil.com is the Myspace of the Apocalypse."
Tyler_JC
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 5438
Joined: Sat 25 Sep 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Boston, MA

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby NEOPO » Sat 07 Oct 2006, 22:46:32

I understand.
So does anyone see the link between those with the most education and their collective leaning toward doomerism?

I say it is false and something wrong that they have learned and are now unable to overcome it.
It is easier to enslave a people that wish to remain free then it is to free a people who wish to remain enslaved.
User avatar
NEOPO
Permanently Banned
 
Posts: 3588
Joined: Sun 15 May 2005, 03:00:00
Location: THE MATRIX

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby AgentR » Sat 07 Oct 2006, 23:12:49

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('NEOPO', 'I') understand.
So does anyone see the link between those with the most education and their collective leaning toward doomerism?
I say it is false and something wrong that they have learned and are now unable to overcome it.


Could be, in the course of education they've seen enough examples of political realities dominating physical possibilities, that they understand that even if one could design a physically possible response to Peak Oil and/or Global Warming, it would be so far outside the realm of the physically possible that its laughable to give it more than a footnote's mention.
Yes, we are. As we are.
And so shall we remain; Until the end.
User avatar
AgentR
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1946
Joined: Fri 06 Oct 2006, 03:00:00
Location: East Texas

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby WildRose » Sun 08 Oct 2006, 00:30:31

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Kylon', 'I')t's well known that men on average prefer to read/learn about factual things, then read fictional novels.

The fact of the matter is, education is geared for girls, and this is completely intentional.



A few things I've observed about the educational system (in Alberta - could be very different from where you are), through my years as a parent/school volunteer/education student:

Boys usually do prefer to read nonfiction, but many girls also do (I always prefered the factual stuff). I think people who prefer nonfiction are the ones who later go on to careers in journalism, reporting, etc. As far as the subjects we all study in school, traditionally boys have achieved higher marks and shown greater interest in maths and sciences, whereas girls are better with the language arts. Again, this is a generalization because many women go on to study commerce and medicine, and other areas that were dominated by men in the past. I really think that each person has aptitudes which determine the subjects they shine in.

I don't know what the exact percentages are currently for male/female high school dropout rates, but when I look around I see about the same number of young girls as boys working at low-paying jobs during the day when you know they would be at school, if they were still in school. I think the school system is inadequate for many girls as well as boys, and I'll tell you why.

The system is really geared for preparing kids for college degrees. Course content in the core subjects grows every year (ask any teacher if it gets any easier from year to year to cover everything they need to with their class). Course content becomes more difficult all the time (what students learned in grade 11 five years ago is now being taught in grade 9, etc.). Not all students are wired for high academic achievement, constant studying, homework for hours every day. The ones who can achieve this move along at the desired rate and a lot of the time, teachers teach for the percentage of the class that can do this. Those students who struggle with this are basically left to their own - find a tutor, get mom and dad's help on a daily basis, whatever. By the time these kids reach high school, they're often overwhelmed, their confidence has all but disappeared, they haven't had a chance to develop the areas where they have talent, which a lot of the time is in the hands-on skills such as carpentry, mechanics, cooking, art.

I can't help but think that if the kids who have aptitudes in the hands-on skills had more opportunity to study in these areas, including job placements to put what they've learned into practice, they would be much more likely to enjoy school and get their diplomas. Awarding kids for their achievements in these areas would also help. For many years, I've watched as the same students, always high academic achievers, received award after award while those who do truly excellent work in other areas are not recognized. After a while, they start to believe they are just not capable.

I also think that the way instruction is delivered to students has traditionally favored girls. Young girls typically can sit for longer periods of time than boys. Girls are also quieter than boys and not as easily distracted. If the structure of a class doesn't allow for these features in boys, what happens is they make more trips to the office, don't absorb material as well as the girls, and they end up being diagnosed by educators as having attention-deficit disorders. Of course, this is not to say that some girls don't have the same problems in school, but they're more common in boys.

Praise also goes a long way in developing students, as does recognition of each student's good ideas and talents. These steps could go a long way in helping students in their social development and achievement. Whenever I meet young kids who have left high school, I wonder in which ways the system has failed them.
User avatar
WildRose
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1881
Joined: Wed 21 Jun 2006, 03:00:00

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby Aaron » Sun 08 Oct 2006, 07:56:07

Ok, here's a little nugget to stir up this thread.

No degree of any sort here.

Not even a high school diploma... :)

NADA

Despite this limitation, I have attended thousands of hours in technology & other post-grad courses... as the teacher.

My very first technology course was TCP/IP custom sub-netting & super-netting... basically a nightmare of hex to binary to decimal conversions.

I was the instructor.

I've trained thousands of highly technical folks over the years, extending on what they didn't really learn as college students.

Most of this coursework I did for companies like Novell, Microsoft, Sun etc...

I'm an accomplished musician, and have worked professionally for many years teaching & performing. (Sax, flute, guitar, clarinet, vocals, percussion etc...)

An avid reader since childhood, I consume a variety of literature on the order of about 3 novels per month.

There's a word for folks like me... but you college boys probably didn't cover it in your estrogen studies curriculum.

Know Thyself.
The problem is, of course, that not only is economics bankrupt, but it has always been nothing more than politics in disguise... economics is a form of brain damage.

Hazel Henderson
User avatar
Aaron
Resting in Peace
 
Posts: 5998
Joined: Thu 15 Apr 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Houston

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby Aaron » Sun 08 Oct 2006, 10:23:09

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'T')he deeper they got into the bankruptcy process, however, the more isolated Tammy became. With her spending cut off, she went through what Dan saw as withdrawal. She worried that the children would be forced to give up their activities and that they would see themselves as different from their friends.


msn
The problem is, of course, that not only is economics bankrupt, but it has always been nothing more than politics in disguise... economics is a form of brain damage.

Hazel Henderson
User avatar
Aaron
Resting in Peace
 
Posts: 5998
Joined: Thu 15 Apr 2004, 03:00:00
Location: Houston

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby firestarter » Sun 08 Oct 2006, 10:50:55

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Aaron', 'O')k, here's a little nugget to stir up this thread.

No degree of any sort here.

Not even a high school diploma... :)

NADA

Despite this limitation, I have attended thousands of hours in technology & other post-grad courses... as the teacher.

My very first technology course was TCP/IP custom sub-netting & super-netting... basically a nightmare of hex to binary to decimal conversions.

I was the instructor.

I've trained thousands of highly technical folks over the years, extending on what they didn't really learn as college students.

Most of this coursework I did for companies like Novell, Microsoft, Sun etc...

I'm an accomplished musician, and have worked professionally for many years teaching & performing. (Sax, flute, guitar, clarinet, vocals, percussion etc...)

An avid reader since childhood, I consume a variety of literature on the order of about 3 novels per month.

There's a word for folks like me... but you college boys probably didn't cover it in your estrogen studies curriculum.

Know Thyself.







Then you'd probably enjoy this little net nugget from Aaron Falbel, HERE

I read his brief piece about seven years ago in between classes (I taught high school AP History and Government...and Wood shop--I came from four generations of German carpenters) and within a year of the reading I left the profession, and sizeable income, for good.

Honestly, much of what I've gleaned, with lasting value, came OUTSIDE the classroom. With all the knowledge out there to be had no one person comes remotely close to being a complete repositiory of all there is to know. Credentialed folk, beyond their narrow specialties, don't impress me in the least. The ones that do impress me, however, are the ones who acknowledge just how pedestrian there knowledge base is. Phd's can be some of the most arrogant, lightweights you'd ever want to rub elbows with. I'm much more impressed with the totality of knowledge (that which is contained in large librarys for instance) but not with it's residence in a temporal singularity.
User avatar
firestarter
Heavy Crude
Heavy Crude
 
Posts: 1171
Joined: Sun 19 Mar 2006, 04:00:00

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby MrBill » Mon 09 Oct 2006, 05:04:12

Interesting poll Tyler_JC. Quite a strong bias even with only 65 votes to date. Confirms to the Pareto Principle. 80% with some college or university or an advanced degree versus only 20% without.

Although I have an advanced degree (or two) I would not underestimate the role of life-long, casual learning either. Learned more from reading The Economist cover to cover each week than from high school or university. And I would not have improved my language skills at all from reading books, but only from watching TV. So different learning methods depending on how you learn and what it is your trying to learn I suppose?

Also, yesterday watched some really, good, informative TV about science, technology and manufacturing for example. Good stuff. But on German TV not US stations. So it really is what you choose to watch versus all TV being mind rotting because sometimes you just need to shut-off and relax as well.
The organized state is a wonderful invention whereby everyone can live at someone else's expense.
User avatar
MrBill
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 5630
Joined: Thu 15 Sep 2005, 03:00:00
Location: Eurasia

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby Doly » Mon 09 Oct 2006, 05:33:01

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrBill', 'C')onfirms to the Pareto Principle. 80% with some college or university or an advanced degree versus only 20% without.


Well, if you put enough options in a poll, some or other or some combination of something or other is going to be around 20%.

The Pareto principle, as normally stated, is a bit stronger than that. It says things like 80% of the money usually comes from 20% of customers. It is an observation that normally fits things that take an approximately exponential distribution (that is, when there is a small number of big fish and a big number of small fish).

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrBill', '
')Although I have an advanced degree (or two) I would not underestimate the role of life-long, casual learning either.


I'd say that self-directed learning is a lot more useful than university degrees. I know, I have a degree in maths (which is supposed to be quite difficult), and that's peanuts in comparison with all the things I've been stuffing in my brain since I was little.
User avatar
Doly
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 4370
Joined: Fri 03 Dec 2004, 04:00:00
Top

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby MrBill » Mon 09 Oct 2006, 05:39:34

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Doly', '')$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrBill', 'C')onfirms to the Pareto Principle. 80% with some college or university or an advanced degree versus only 20% without.


Well, if you put enough options in a poll, some or other or some combination of something or other is going to be around 20%.

The Pareto principle, as normally stated, is a bit stronger than that. It says things like 80% of the money usually comes from 20% of customers. It is an observation that normally fits things that take an approximately exponential distribution (that is, when there is a small number of big fish and a big number of small fish).

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrBill', '
')Although I have an advanced degree (or two) I would not underestimate the role of life-long, casual learning either.


I'd say that self-directed learning is a lot more useful than university degrees. I know, I have a degree in maths (which is supposed to be quite difficult), and that's peanuts in comparison with all the things I've been stuffing in my brain since I was little.


Except the distribution is not normal. It is skewed to the right to higher education and would have been more skewed had Tyler_JC not included Other as one of the choices as I am not sure what this should be? PhD or apprenticeship for example?

I would interpret the Pereto Principle to this forum as 80% of the people thinking about peak oil are the 80% that have some form of higher education. That does not negate in anyway the other 20%. It just tells me anecdotally that the other 80% who have less education do not care about peak oil, are unaware of it or have less access to the Internet, etc.
The organized state is a wonderful invention whereby everyone can live at someone else's expense.
User avatar
MrBill
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 5630
Joined: Thu 15 Sep 2005, 03:00:00
Location: Eurasia
Top

Re: Education Level Poll

Unread postby Doly » Mon 09 Oct 2006, 06:13:31

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrBill', '
')Except the distribution is not normal.


Did I ever say normal in my post? I only mentioned an exponential distribution. Which is definitely not normal. Normal is bell-shaped. Exponential is skewed to one end. Like the distribution of income in a nation, for example. Few rich people and a lot more poor people.

Anyway, I did not comment on the distribution of the poll, because I'm not too certain what it is. Skewed, certainly, but not skewed enough to be exponential, in my opinion.

$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('MrBill', '
')I would interpret the Pereto Principle to this forum as 80% of the people thinking about peak oil are the 80% that have some form of higher education. That does not negate in anyway the other 20%. It just tells me anecdotally that the other 80% who have less education do not care about peak oil, are unaware of it or have less access to the Internet, etc.


If every time you see an 80% or 20% you call it Pareto principle, you are misusing the word. That's what I was trying to say at the beginning. Pareto principle normally implies that 80% of something is related to 20% of something else.

If you see that 80% of peakoilers have higher education, my conclusion would be that knowing about peak oil is correlated with having higher education. Which is logical, if you think that the subject is technical enough to require some practice in absorbing difficult information.
User avatar
Doly
Expert
Expert
 
Posts: 4370
Joined: Fri 03 Dec 2004, 04:00:00
Top

Previous

Return to Open Topic Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests

cron