by urlich » Mon 15 May 2006, 03:15:53
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Zardoz', ' ')Forget the clay tablet stuff. We'll never fall that far.
I think that my post was (in part) misunderstood, maybe because I am not a native English speaker.
The reason of my post was simply this:
The History has been written always by the winners.
When Peak Oil will come the winners in general will be the survivors but the real "Winners" will be the new kings (if we return to kingdoms) or the new dictators, in short the new leaders. *They* will be free to write, to alter the History of Peak.
They could say, for example, that oil is abundant in the hand of the enemy so we must fight to have it; as in the past the "elite" will be able to find excuses to make crusades against this or that current enemy.
Or, another example, they will say that we must work as slaves to find the "ultimate" energy source, the panacea of the world. "We are only one meter before the goal", they will say.
Remember "1984" by Orwell.
They will not tell the people the truth: that oil is a scarce resource, that we have passed the peak (maybe they will _never_ tell that word) that some sources of oil have a EROEI < 1, that in Nature there is no Free Lunch, no, they will continue to lie, to deceive, as they do now.
This was the meaning of my post. Even in a worst case scenario how to make sure that the True Story will be tramandated?
Maybe even with censorship, imprisoments.
The true story is that fighting for energy sources is pointless, that humanity will have to find sustainable way of living in closed (or nearly closed) environments.
We'll never fall to clay tablet, that's possible. The "Winners" will never fall to it, that's certainly true. They will continue to have Plasma tvs and air conditioning. But it is not certain if we (POilers) will fall in the "winners" team, and, more important, if we will always free to tell our story; but this is probably another "mental masturbation" as somebody told.