by nth » Thu 16 Mar 2006, 19:51:05
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ClassicSpiderman', '
')If I could just play Devil's Advocate here...
I've always wondered why the US chooses to not let it's dollar collapse. If foreigners hold most of the US debt, wouldn't it be in the interest of the US government out of pure self-interest to let the dollar slide really low (to say 25 cents Canadian) and just tell the other countries holding US debt "too bad so sad" ?
A depressed US dollar would do wonders for it's export industry as well. And it would hurt other countries (especially India & China) because their meal ticket comes from their trade surplus with the US. Even if the other countries protested by disallowing US imports, the US trade deficit would shrink down to zero anyhow.
The only reason I can see why the US government and industry want a high dollar in spite of it's huge trade deficit is to have access to energy on the world market. It would be a completely different scenario is the US could produce most if not all of its energy needs. Instead, the US has to import 60% of it's energy. The US might even achieve full employment if it had a really low dollar but American workers would be paying $10 a gallon for gas and $8 for a loaf of bread.
Okay, let's separate the issues to simplify it.
First, let's discuss what happens when US dollar drops.
1. US debt is in US$, so it will not be easier to payoff this debt.
US can payoff the debt by printing more money and simply paying off US bonds. This may not change the strength of the US$ as foreign US$ holders will simply invest in other US securities or investments. China invests heavily in Asset-Backed securities. What this will cause then is hyper inflation in the US.
2. US Dollar drop will mean people will not be able to buy stuff. Retail stores, transportation, etc will get reduce. If US needs to make everything themselves, then US cost of living will rise. A lot of goods simply cannot be made due to expensive labor. People don't want to work and do menial jobs for low wages that force them to work long hours for minimum wage. Other countries have people that are willing to do this.
Second, why US wants US$ high.
Yes, strong dollar can buy more goods. It enables US to continue to grow its economy. The more the dollar can buy allows US citizens to live a high standard of living that they otherwise could not afford. Of course, this includes energy/oil. So I agree with you.