by NordicThora » Mon 17 Oct 2005, 23:29:27
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('SurvivalAcres', 'A')ncient civilizations had it much better then we do and we could return to this if needed - if we don't totally screw things up between now and then - which we might.
SurvivalAcres,
Thank you for a thought-provoking post. I can relate very well to pretty much everything you say here, and I thoroughly share your frustration. The difference is that I'm coming at this from the "opposite" angle. I've found myself very frustrated with the naive idealism of many in the "intentional community" and eco-village movement (and even my own rapidly fading idealism), and have moved more toward a "survivalist" mentality over time. Neither "side" really suits me, however; I've grown so weary of the ideological battles and what you call the "flash-in-the-pan" types that I can't really place myself in either of those camps. I call myself a doomer, but I hardly fit the stereotype.
My companion and I own some land in Oregon, chosen partly with post-crash survival in mind. We recently tried to start an ecovillage from the ground up, quite literally. In spite of our best efforts and immense amounts of research, planning, and sheer determination, we failed. The hardest part of getting a group together, I think, is finding the right mix of people. Even with skilled, intelligent, committed, and like-minded people (which we had), it is damn hard for people raised in an insane culture like this to pull this off.
To add to the difficulty, we faced out-and-out ridicule from certain family members, and endless "well-meaning" but annoying advice from friends who thought we were out of our minds to quit our jobs and try to drop out of society. Eventually it got to a point where we avoided some of these people, because it was awfully draining to be on the defensive all the time. This contributed to isolation, which certainly didn't help.
Another curious thing: since we tried to do this, we've become a lightning rod for people's unfulfilled dreams. When they hear we're building a tiny cabin in the forest, they say "oh, I've always wanted to do that, but..." and then launch into a lengthy justification of why they simply can't. The kids aren't out of school yet, hubby wouldn't go for it, maybe when I win the lottery, etc. I realize that debt slavery and all kinds of other things come into play here, and I know there is some truth to these justifications in some cases. But the frequency with which we are subjected to these "explanations" from perfectly capable people suggests to me that there are a whole lot of unfulfilled people out there who would rather offer excuses than go for the brass ring, so to speak. It's all very sad. Thoreau was right when he said the masses live lives of quiet desperation.
Anyway, I don't know if the larger problem is that most people refuse to help themselves, but I do get the sense that few people are willing to start things from the ground up and put in the time, work, and money that is required to take that route. Most prefer to join something that's already built. We as a culture are indeed quite addicted to our petroleum-fueled way of life and the mentality that goes with it. It is very hard for addicts to give up their addictions even under the best conditions. I suspect that the harsh reality is that most people will refuse (whether by simple inertia or neglect, inability, lack of social support, or lack of willpower) to change their way of life until TSHTF for them personally, and of course by then it will be far too late.
Humans are definitely tribal creatures, and I think ancient tribes got it right the first time. A small portion of us could "return" to this way of life (but puh-leeeze don't get me started ranting about the "you can't go back" and the "don't romanticize the noble savages" crowd)! There are small groups of very courageous people who are trying to do it - drop out of society completely, or at least as much as possible. I count myself among this group, but my track record isn't too good so far despite immense effort. It is MUCH harder than it may seem, psychologically and otherwise.
One of the biggest problems is, as you say, the social one - finding serious people who are willing to make the break. So many of us are living in "nuclear" families and are isolated. How do we un-learn this way of life? Frankly, I suspect few people are going to do it.
Even those who are truly serious about it and not just playing Internet games, as you put it, face immense challenges. Only the most fortunate, diligent, and determined people will manage to pull this off, I think. There probably are a few (VERY few!) here who are serious about it, but when push comes to shove, they may balk. I'm not even sure about my own level of commitment lately. I've done an immense amount of soul-searching on this, and there are many times when I wonder if it wouldn't be better to "go down with the ship" instead of putting all my time and attention into trying to build a lifeboat, if you catch my drift.
Still, something stubborn inside me insists that I've got to keep plugging and hope for the best (yet continue to plan for the worst, of course). So I don't intend to give up, despite my frustration and the fact that I seriously waver at times.
Anyway, I wish you the best of luck with building a community. If my experience is any indication, you're going to need it.
-Thora