by MrBill » Thu 02 Feb 2006, 09:16:27
The fixed income universe is simply too broad for one pat answer to that question. There are many types of bond funds. Some invest only in OECD, government debt with investment grade ratings, while others specialize in sub-investment grade corporate credits, emerging market and distressed debt. Some are hedged against US treasuries and others run a higher Alpha risk or even take on leverage to enhance the risk/return.
Personally, I find it very unsettling that any company can pursue policies that reward shareholders while penalizing its debt holders by for example issuing more debt to pay for leverage buy-outs, share buy backs or dividends. That ain't right, Ma'am. I would have been one pissed off bond holder had I held AT&T when they decided to split up into four separate Baby Bells. Just some of the risks bond holders potentially face.
Of course, if you hold senior secured debt you may stand at the front of the line if there is a bankruptcy, but personally I do not like to invest in companies that are likely to go bankrupt. Sovereign bonds by nature of their ability to raise revenues via general taxation are quite secure from default, but you may still run other risks like currency devaluation and/or see domestic inflation eat into your returns.
Emerging market bonds have performed very well over the past several years (EMBI +13.8% in 2005), but that was due to a) falling global inflation, b) lower US interest rates, c) high commodity prices, and d) better macromanagement (but I would not place too much weight on that last point, it is easier to be prudent in a benign environment). However, I doubt going forward for how long can we rely on these same factors to continue, for example, US interest rates are still moving higher and higher energy & commodity prices may push up inflation as well.
So, I cannot tell you equity will outperform fixed income or vice versa, but whichever bond fund you choose, just make sure you know what instruments the fund manager is going to invest in and make sure you agree with the logic of their approach. As a hedge against inflation, bond funds are not generally very good (except if they buy inflation indexed bonds or other such exotic instruments like IRSs). As a hedge against market turbulence investment grade bonds usually are not too bad (flight to quality and all that jazz).
Hmm, isn't this where someone tells me, forget bonds or equities, the only hedge for the future is gold? ; - )
The organized state is a wonderful invention whereby everyone can live at someone else's expense.