by MrBill » Tue 18 Oct 2005, 05:28:32
If you're trapped in a burning house, you want to be able to get out and the quicker the better. Unfortunately, many mutual funds, asset & portfolio managers of public funds are only legally allowed to invest in certain kinds of products. Imagine being only long bonds while interest rates are going up or long stocks during a downward correction. These are the long only, fully invested type of funds. The only way to get any diversification is to invest in several funds or take your money out of one and invest in another.
Hedge funds on the otherhand have the ability to go long or go short and to take advantage of whatever market happens to be moving. It may be European stocks markets and energy markets this year and the Chinese yuan next year. Also, they have the discretion not to invest, just sit on cash until a chance comes along, or in fact as was mentioned to borrow so that they can take bigger bets. For example, buy US treasuries, pledge those US treasuries against a loan and buy more US treasuries. A wonderful strategy when interest rates are falling, but dangerous once they start rising.
If I am long stocks, I may not want to sell my long position if I feel they might go higher. Therefore, I may sell an option, which is a derivative, to cap my upside while giving me some downside protection in the form of my premium. Money for nothing as I was prepared to be long in any case.
However, suppose a fund manager is not happy with the 4.5% yield on US treasuries. So he visits Bill the Banker and Mr.Bill! says, no problem, I will guarantee you a yield of 5.5%, so long as US treasuries stay below 5.5% for the next 10-years, but if they go higher, you have to pay me twice the difference between 5.5% and the current yield if the yield goes above 5.5%. If you're view is lower interest rates, you might take that bet. If you're wrong you would have to pay. If you borrowed the money to take that bet, it could all go terribly wrong, if we saw yields head north of 5.5%.
But, it is not blackbox voodoo. The pricing is straight forward and so is the obligation. I pay you a yield of 5.5% if the yield is anywhere below 5.5% no matter how low it goes. If the yield is above 5.5% you pay me double. However, as it is a contingent liability from an accounting point of view it would not be prudent to book your profits until maturity. In reality, you would book profits on the difference between 4.5% and 5.5% to flatter your own performace. Doing a great job. Get a bonus. However, there is still an unrealized liability until the contract matures. That is what Mr. Buffet is referring to. Profits all of a sudden turning into losses.
In this case, the fund manager should have either accepted the 4.5% yield on existing treasuries or invested in something else.
The organized state is a wonderful invention whereby everyone can live at someone else's expense.