by PhilBiker » Fri 26 Aug 2005, 16:54:19
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('richardmmm', 'i') always found that the savings on regular were replaced by loss of efficiency and gas mileage, plus the car becomes more of a dog to drive.
So I began to break the regular savings myth lately, and use premium.
Week to week it cost about the same, giving better mileage, but costing more. But the car drives much better and smoother and the purity is better for the engine.
I figure the whole thing is a con in the end.
It's like asking if you want to get drunk on whiskey or beer.
Sure a bottle of one costs more than the other but basically the end result and costs per night out work out to be about the same, and whiskey saves you a lot of time in the john

Bunk.
The whiskey or beer analogy is far too extreme. The difference in gas grades is more like skim milk versus 2% milk versus whole milk. All three are milk, all three are just as good, but one key ingredient is different in a very small, but important way (amount of fat). Is one better than the others? Depends on what you want from your milk. Want rich creamy taste? Whole is best. Want less fat? Skim is better. Want both? Get 2%. They're all just as good.
If the engine you're using is not specifically built to take advantage of high octane gas (many are these days, particularly performance cars) you're throwing money away and wasting crude (it takes more crude to make premium) by using it. Consult your owner's manual for the octane your car is made for. Most non-performance cars run perfect on 87. On my wife's sportscar the mileage suffers badly if we use 87. On my touring motorcycle and my car anything over 87 does nothing but lighten my wallet.
If your owners manual says that the car requires 87 and it runs better or gets better mileage on 93, something is wrong. It's probable that running the higher octane is covering up a problem somewhere that needs to be addressed. Get a tune up.
Most lawn mowers require high octane gas.
"Premium" or "super" or whatever are nothing but manipulative brand names designed by corporations to make you feel like the higher octane gas is somehow "better" than lower octane gasoline. Of course you want "the best" for your car, right? You're a sucker if you buy it and your car doesn't need it.