by Outcast_Searcher » Fri 08 Dec 2017, 16:28:17
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ROCKMAN', 'O')utcast - The SEC once used the closing oil price on 31 December for reserve determination. Changed a few years ago. Now it uses an average price determined I think monthly. I'm sure Doc can offer details. But the SEC reserve determination only applies to US publicly traded companies. Neither private US companies nor any international companies have their reserves independently audited as US publicly traded companies as far as I know. IOW they are free claim half of what they estimate or 3X as much and no one is in a position to dispute their numbers. They can provide you with maps, production numbers, etc. and you have no way to confirm the accuracy. You're certainly free to not believe them but you have no FACTS available to prove them liars. For I instance I can write an article claiming my horizontal redevelopment project has added 5 million bbls of proven reserves. You can't prove me a liar. And since I work with a private company and claim confidentiality of my trade secrets I don't have to prove sh*t to you.
Nothing personal, buddy. Just good business. LOL.
Thanks for the info and the perspective, Rockman.
The reason I brought that up was the silly season estimate numbers which have been used by the Middle Eastern OPEC countries for decades, where politics, desire to maximize countries' production quotas, etc. seem to have at least as much weight as following production trends, geology, etc. (at least, to this layman).
Your insight pretty much confirms what I'd thought the risk might be, in terms of such numbers.
Of course, this is pretty much true of industry in general. For example, Musk tells investers what (we hope) he believes re production estimates. Not only does he not have any accountability re being remotely close to correct -- he doesn't even have to disclose monthly production to let investors benchmark actual progress against marketing claims.
Given the track record of the perma-doomer blogs, I wouldn't bet a fast crash doomer's money on their predictions.