by AdamB » Sat 20 Feb 2016, 13:45:21
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ROCKMAN', 'A')dam - It's not that the SEC is allowed to set the prices but demands that public companies use their pricing protocols. And there are no future pricing estimates as part of their rules. Some years ago pubcos were required BY LAW to use the closing price of oil on 31 Dec to project the future value of their reserves. Now they are using something more like a rolling average.
If you are making a NPV calculation for today, and using any value of production from tomorrow to do that, you are most certainly making an estimate of future price. No way to avoid it. So the SEC assumes that the price over the timespan of oil and gas reserves, often measured in decades, decide that it will be the same as today, or on Dec 31. Fine. They, like everyone else, are likely to be wrong. But that estimate must be made, for anything future looking, and reserves are all about future looking.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('ROCKMAN', '
')In my 40 years the most hard nosed and pessimistic deserve estimators were the ones working on behalf of the lending institutions. Typically not their employees but companies that specialize in this process. Like Ryder-Scott and Gruey. Trust me: no bank gives any validity to the numbers coming out of the pubcos. For many years a major part of my efforts was jousting with those consulting geologists and engineers. And I actually had developed a decent reputation for holding my own against them. I never lied or presented false data but I was very good at spinning "facts". LOL.