by Sixstrings » Mon 07 Jul 2014, 00:48:51
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('C8', '[')b]PO argument: yes we are producing more oil- but look at the costs!
Counterargument: oil prices have been stable the last 3 years and are lower than $140 a barrel over 6 years ago- besides which, given what oil can do and how concentrated and energy source it is- it is still a killer bargain at this price. And BTW- inflation has raised the price of many things- why do you still expect oil to be $30 a barrel?
Yup, that's what I've observed in the peak oil discussion as the years go on.
First it was that shale and tar sands would never work out, and a long list of reasons why. Now they've clearly "worked out," but there's still the "but but but."
I've been on the forum long enough to remember folks said EV's would never work out. But, they did.
On and on like that. But just saying this is touching that third rail and sticking a finger in a hornet's nest, though peak oilers are nicer than climate change folks when you point things out -- it's more like that SNL episode with Shatner at the Star Trek convention telling them to all "get a life." People are just disappointed their bubble is popped.
I don't want to be a anti-doom troll, there's plenty of doom out there it's just not really from peak oil, not right now anyhow and I don't guess there will be any oil doom until 2030?
We need something else to talk about between then and now, no?
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', '[')b]PO argument: But we are still going to run out someday so this news is worthless
Counterargument: yes we will run out, but "when" makes all the difference- with enough time we can transition to other energy sources smoothly- plus research is leading to more energy efficient living.
More time changes everything
That'll be interesting to see how that goes -- on the one hand, I can't see the world's poor masses actually all using fusion power one day. Are there even enough rare earths for solar panels all over the planet?
What about infrastructure? Africa's been a mess for a long time, is it really going to be modern in a hundred years and full of fusion power plants? And South America, too? OTOH.. take a look at South America, and Brazil. They grow sugar, use it for a big chunk of their fuel needs as ethanol, and they do well with that. (sugar is really good for ethanol though, much better than corn)
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', '[')b]Counterargument: this reveals Peak Oil as a faith based movement- not a science based one. There is simply no way to predict the pace and course of future scientific discoveries. The greatest flaw of PO is that is
- it is simply accepted as a "Peak Oil Truth." It is in this dogmatic belief that the PO is revealed as more of a religious viewpoint than a rational one. A group so united by the desire to see collapse that objectivity is no longer welcome.