by Sixstrings » Fri 13 Apr 2012, 12:20:03
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Plantagenet', 'G')ive me a break.
Obama is such a dunce he doesn't even know that the Supreme court has been overturning laws passed by Congress ever since the Constitution was ratified.
Actually I was disappointed when Obama came out and clarified his remarks, and stressed that of course he will respect SCOTUS decisions blah blah.
The fact is..
The president is an equal branch of government and he's totally free to harangue, criticize, and call the SCOTUS out for being partisan scoundrels. Read your history.
Andrew Jackson once said something like "that's a fine decision, let THEM enforce it." That was the Cherokee Indian case.. Jackson simply ignored the ruling and force marched the Cherokee on the trail of tears. That's an example of going too far, Plant, Obama isn't ignoring rulings he's just exercising his constitutional free speech.
FDR trying to pack the supreme court.. maybe that was going too far.. but FDR's threats worked and he got most of his programs upheld, PEOPLE WERE FRICKIN STARVING IN THE GREAT DEPRESSION the times were HORRIBLE and Republicans did not give a damn.
Plant, the SCOTUS is not God. We have three equal branches of government for a reason.. if one gets too out of control, the system is designed for one or the other branch to step in. SCOTUS rulings must be followed of course, but any president is free to call them out and shame them and expose their questionable personal political ties to Tea Party groups etc.
Republicans are something else, honestly, for so many years they complained about activist judges -- now with this court, Republicans want us to just be quiet and let them legislate from the bench (they're even using Tea Party lingo and talking points, one federal judge called the health reform law "Obamacare.")
Plant, judges aren't perfect we MUST have free speech at least. About a month ago, there was one federal judge who was sending racist Obama jokes from his court email.

Nothing you can do about it, lifetime appointment -- we need free speech at minimum as a check on their power, and that right to free speech includes the President.