by AgentR11 » Sun 25 Sep 2011, 12:14:48
The problem with comparisons to the depression era, deflation, and prices, is that the currency was on the gold standard, so the thing that moved in the economic equation was the price of goods, based upon how much people have to spend. In our current depression, the currency is fiat, and what the fed is attempting to do is to keep the price of goods stable in the face of what would normally be a reduction in the money available to spend. You see this in unemployment, and the amount of cash reserves that companies feel they need to hold in order to survive what is coming. Without the fed playing with the amount of money available to spend, we'd have long since been in the position of $1 gasoline, but that $1 gasoline being a MUCH larger portion of people's household budgets. And, at this particular job, the fiat currencies have so far performed spectacularly well.
The problem I see with it, is that in a normal depression, its easy to see the total economy brutally contract, know there is a problem, and respond with real determination, whichever solution one might wish to choose. With this fiat mask and tuning, everyone with a fully employed wage earner in their family knows something is afoot, but can blissfully believe that most of the suffering belongs to others, and their own suffering is limited to some odd price changes in food and fuel. There is no way to not notice the distress though, when you head to the grocery store, especially if you choose the "non-trendy" variety of store. [(insert name of a certain high-end 'organic' store) remains an oblivious island of the upper middle class and lesser nobility, for example] Kinda wrenching to wander around the store buying whatever strikes you as interesting while a mom,dad, and baby unit are carefully trying to get as much food as they can for the $8 in their pocket. I prefer the Latino markets and a certain Texas chain that is well subscribed by those on the bottom of the economic ladder, because the produce really does move and is always stuff that is fresh off the truck, so I get a pretty full plate load of this on a regular basis. How else can an upper middle class person or member of the lower nobility respond to this observation, other than "there but by the grace of God go I", and "I need to save more, spend less, because something is f****** up." That is a depression era response... and yet we have low overall inflation, and modest inflation on food and fuel.
Bernanke (ridicule him or not) has performed a miracle of unmatched scale and bravado; but its concerned with a subject so grim that none dare acknowledge the truth of what he has achieved.
And yes, I'm still a right wing extremist, but praise is due where praise is due.
Yes we are, as we are,
And so shall we remain,
Until the end.