by Carlhole » Tue 14 Jun 2011, 11:30:43
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Cog', 'T')here are an infinite number of free energy scams out there so I would suspect that Carhole will not run out of things to post about. He is like OF2 in this way, trumpeting the certainty of endless growth in a resource constrained world.
Oh, fark you.
The first thing I did when I became aware of Dr. Jones' circuit was email my Dad, who has worked in energy all his life.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'I') am an engineer who was thoroughly exposed to the physics and thermodynamics that most engineers need to be exposed to. Sorry, but I agree with the following:-
Claims of Over Unity
Search on YouTube for Over Unity and you will find a plethora of people claiming to have invented some sort of free energy device, mostly in the form of a motor, which apparently generates more power than is used to drive it. Others claim to have invented some arrangement of permanent magnets whereby a flywheel will, by the arrangement of these magnets, move on their own for ever.
Anybody claiming to have invented a machine which creates energy, I'm afraid to say, is either trying to con you, or is deluded or confused. It is fair enough to have an open mind when i comes to the possibility of new Physics, but this is not new Physics. This is quite old Physics. Frankly, if they were to violate the laws of thermodynamics, then all of modern technology would be based on the wrong foundations. Since everything is still running smoothly, based on these laws, we can assume that these garage inventions are not what they seem.
Not only that, but why would they have created these machines in their garages, promoting it on YouTube? They would have papers in peer reviewed journals, and if their discoveries were true, there would be no shortage of Nobel Prizes. Please do not be drawn in by these claims, which seem to be growing in popularity.
But the story is interesting nonetheless since (1) Jones is a PhD physicist with 55 published papers in journals like Nature and so forth, (2) it's a simple circuit design, easily replicated by anyone for under $50, and (3) Jones specifically put out a call to anyone interested in this circuit to please investigate it for themselves and make sure to make careful measurements.
Pass this on to your friends and favorite news sources.
Get involved in replicating this.
Get involved in commercializing this.