by Oakley » Tue 28 Dec 2010, 21:29:22
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Questionmark', 'T')he problem I have with Libertarianism is how strictly it wishes to apply free market capitalism. Libertarians operate under the assumption that consumers are rational and that markets are efficient, and yet we've seen time and time again that this isn't true. They just refuse to acknowledge reality. Libertarianism is just anarchy, and we all know how effective of a system anarchy is.
One end of the political spectrum is total freedom (anarchy) and the other is total subjugation (totalitarianism). You don't know how effective anarchy is because we have never had it. If you are talking about extremist who plant bombs to gain politically, they are not anarchist, because this is not something freedom loving people do; generally these bombers have been extreme leftists.
Libertarians do endorse minimum government, i.e., they want individual freedom with some government enforcement of human rights and punishment of those who commit acts of aggression against others, so they are not anarchist.
What we have in the US today is something much closer to the complete subjugation end of the spectrum than the anarchy end. And if you look at the progression of government expansion in the US, we are running headlong in the direction of complete subjugation.
The consequences of begging for more government to take care of you are dire. Just look at the deterioration of our rights under Bush and Obama as they fight this bogus war on terror. As Ron Paul has pointed out, our interventionist foreign policy created the hatred that brought about 9/11. But instead of taking a rational course or ending the US empire, the federal government has chosen to expand its control over us all. They are even now talking about a new "sedition act" to limit free speech that is critical of government.
As far as your comment about rational consumers and efficient markets, you are way off base. Do you actually think the government controlled markets that plunder the majority are better than free market inefficiencies or some irrational consumers, whatever you even mean by those terms? I think that advocacy of socialism, fascism, corporatism, or whatever similar slave system that government has brought is much more a demonstration of loss of contact with reality than is the advocacy of Libertarianism.