by nth » Fri 13 May 2005, 12:55:51
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('bas', 'I')'ve become very skeptical of sources like the IEA, those are the exact guys that should have sounded the alarm years ago...they didn't!!
%^&*&** Them!
Hrm... I am not that familiar with IEA, but I know a lot of angst against the EIA is uncalled for. Especially given the history of EIA, which called for Peak Oil when USGS gave them data that after EIA analysis states PO was going to happen soon!
They did blow the whistle! And they were wrong!
Check USGS estimates on ultimate recoverable oil in 1984, 1987 when the whistle was blown.
Based on EIA forecasts for demand, they predicted we will hit PO!
(On a side note, Exxon predicted $100 oil price by 2000.)
Okay, after EIA was told they were wrong, a change of events happened.
First, USGS became very aggressive with their estimates, so now EIA won't be forecasting PO.
Second, EIA started reporting two different numbers without combining them- demand and supply. Most people here like to quote EIA demand numbers as they seem impossible to meet, but seldom anyone quote EIA supply numbers which are quite accurate for non-opec. As EIA states that demand minus non-opec supply projections equals OPEC supplies, EIA does not project OPEC supply.
Now, on a totally separate report by different authors and analysts, EIA projects OPEC production. If you look at these numbers, you can easily see OPEC is not going to meet EIA's OPEC supply projections. Actually, even Saudi officials have publicly stated they won't be meeting EIA's OPEC supply projections. As of today, I have yet to see anyone claiming OPEC will meet EIA's OPEC supply projection.
The anti PO people are mostly economists and they don't claim OPEC will meet those projections. They just say the rising price of oil will trigger production increases. They show the mechanism, but they don't show where that oil will appear.
Politicians in US and EU are calling for OPEC to open their doors to US and EU oil firms to exploit OPEC resources to make sure OPEC meets EIA's OPEC supply projections. OPEC has said we are open and they point to the offers last few years that ended with failed bids as oil firms are not interested in 8% returns. That is why Saudi's say they are too greedy.
Now, getting back to topic, most people don't believe EIA, but it is not their fault. They are forced to use USGS numbers. They have forecast the demand and they also forecast supplies. Their supply forecasts are pretty accurate. They do note that any shortfall in production will be matched by OPEC not because they think OPEC can matched, but because OPEC said they will meet the needs of the world's demand for oil. Basically, EIA is saying OPEC policy says they will meet demands, so we will just take their words for it. They also noted the dangers of this and have noted that a certain someone disputes Saudi published data.