Page added on June 5, 2012
IEA Confirms The End Of Cheap Oil, reads one blogger’s headline.
The end of cheap oil – and life as you know it, proclaims the Digital Journal.
Age of Cheap Oil Is Over: IEA’s Chief Economist, says MarketWatch.
Obama Cops to Peak Oil Reality, blares the Post Carbon Institute.
But a funny thing happened on the way to peak oil. As the Wall Street Journal reports:
If historical trading patterns are any indication, U.S. crude-oil prices should continue to fall after plunging 18% in May, traders and analysts said. Oil prices dropped in 17 of 22 trading days last month on the New York Mercantile Exchange, the highest number of losing days in any month since January 1997. That month was the start of a nearly three-year price slide fueled by the Asian economic crisis and oversupply from members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries.
And how low could it go? Pretty darn low:
Walter Zimmermann, chief technical analyst at United-ICAP, points to $80 a barrel as being the watershed price. U.S. crude prices closed down 3.8% at $83.23 a barrel on Friday. He said if the price can stay above $80, chart patterns suggest crude may be completing a bull-market correction—or a sharp downward move that doesn’t disrupt a longer-term trend higher in prices. But “crude oil is in deep trouble if it can’t hold $80,” he said. Such a breach would set up potential for unraveling down to $45 a barrel, Mr. Zimmermann said. That would be something of a re-enactment of the price collapse from a record intraday high of $147.27 a barrel in July 2008 to an intraday low of $32.40 in December 2008. He didn’t offer an opinion whether the $80 price level would hold.
What happens if oil slides to $45.00 a barrel? Well, aside from being a signal of a global economic meltdown, it would be a train-wreck for gasoline alternatives and alternative vehicle technologies. That ethanol we’re required to blend into gasoline becomes even less affordable than it is. The payback period for that Toyota Prius or GM Volt becomes considerably longer than the life-expectancy of the vehicle. And, the prospects for other biofuels, such as algae, are dire.
As energy guru Vaclav Smil has pointed out:
The modern tradition of concerns about an impending decline of resource extraction began in 1865 with Victorian economist William Stanley Jevons (1835–1882), who concluded that falling coal output must spell the end of Britain’s national greatness as it is “of course…useless to think of substituting any other kind of fuel for coal.” Substitute oil for coal in the last sentence and you get the erroneous foundations of the doomsday sentiment shared by the peak-oil catastrophists.
6 Comments on "The end of cheap oil?"
BillT on Tue, 5th Jun 2012 4:11 am
High prices… OUCH!
Low prices… OUCH!
“Catch 22” anyone? ^_^
Grover Lembeck on Tue, 5th Jun 2012 6:02 am
Since most exporting countries have a break even point higher than $45 per barrel, there would be a price correction within months as supply would be taken off line for one reason or another.
The correction would no doubt way over correct. I don’t know if the lull would last nearly as long as the article implies. I also have doubts that oil will ever be allowed to get that low without the grenddaddy of all economic collapses. Production would get cut quickly, well before $45/barrel.
BillT on Tue, 5th Jun 2012 8:38 am
Grover, you are correct. Most of the world’s economies could not take a drop in consumption that it would take to get oil much under $80 and that is about impossible also. At that point, the tar sands would shut down and the fraking for oil would end. They would be huge money losers. But, at that point, there may not be an economic recovery, ever.
dorlomin on Tue, 5th Jun 2012 9:12 am
http://www.theoildrum.com/node/4672
Its a predictable of a constrained comodity oscilating between customers being priced out of the market and production being priced out of business.
Harquebus on Wed, 6th Jun 2012 4:51 am
Great. Now all we have to do is find this replacement.
St. Roy on Thu, 7th Jun 2012 3:29 am
The marginal cost of NEW oil is now about the same as the spot market price for an EROEI of 1:1. We are near the point where it is no longer economical to extract the high cost stuff. The economy as we know it can’t run on less than 5:1, so economic contraction is going to accelerate which is what we are seeing.