Register

Peak Oil is You


Donate Bitcoins ;-) or Paypal :-)

Donate Bitcoin



Donate Paypal

Page added on March 24, 2021

Bookmark and Share

How stalling growth hurts the planet

How stalling growth hurts the planet thumbnail

Some environmentalists and economists are pushing for “degrowth” — stabilizing or even shrinking the economy — to avert environmental catastrophe.

The big picture: Degrowthism may seem like the only reasonable response to the climate challenges we face, but the experience of enforced economic shrinking during the pandemic indicates the pain would outweigh the benefits — especially for the world’s poorest.

Where it stands: The global economy shrank by an estimated 4.3% in 2020, according to data from the World Bank.

  • That contraction was due both to the direct pain of the pandemic and the effects of social distancing measures, but it also led to a roughly 6% reduction in global carbon dioxide emissions — the biggest annual drop since WWII.

How it works: However accidental, 2020 represented perhaps the best example we’ve ever experienced of degrowthism in action.

  • For degrowthers, simply cleaning up the global economy by switching from fossil fuels to zero-carbon sources of energy isn’t enough. Economic growth — the goal of essentially every government everywhere — is itself the problem.
  • Environmental activist Greta Thunberg summed up the argument when she chastised delegates at a UN climate summit in 2019: “We are in the beginning of a mass extinction, and all you can talk about is money and fairy tales of eternal economic growth. How dare you!”
  • The movement now has its own dedicated academic journals, associations and conferences.

The catch: The very real human pain of 2020 — and the political fallout it created — should be taken as a warning sign to degrowthers.

  • A new Pew Research Center analysis found the ranks of the global middle income — those who live on $10.01 to $20 a day — fell by 54 million in 2020 compared to the number projected before the pandemic, while the number of global poor rose by 131 million.
  • And while carbon emissions did fall significantly in 2020, it came at a high cost. One analysis estimated that each ton of CO2 reduced due to pandemic-related degrowth will have an implied cost to the economy of more than $1,500.
  • That’s “an order of magnitude greater than the most costly of ‘technofixes'” like direct capture of carbon from the air, as Ted Nordhaus of the Breakthrough Institute wrote last year.

Between the lines: The strongest argument around degrowth is one rooted in a goal that its own advocates strive for: global equity.

  • In a piece posted earlier this week, economist Max Roser of Our World in Data estimated the amount of global growth required to bring everyone in the world up to the level of poor people in the fairly rich nation of Denmark would be 410%.
  • Whether or not global poverty can be truly conquered — meaning getting everyone at least to the minimum of the developed world — “overwhelmingly depends on whether the average incomes in those countries that are home to the poorest billions of people in the world will increase or not,” Roser writes.

Be smart: With reason, we tend to focus on the huge and growing wealth gap between the ultrarich and the middle class and poor in rich countries like the U.S. But a much bigger gap exists between even the relatively less well-off in the developed world and most of humanity.

  • Take electricity access, one of the basic fundamental requirements for a modern lifestyle: Californians use more electricity just to play video games than the total amount of power consumed by everyone in countries like Ghana and Kenya, according to one estimate.

Flashback: This isn’t the first time the idea of degrowth or economic stasis has been raised. Utilitarian philosopher John Stuart Mill argued in mid-19th century England that “economic growth in the richest countries had run its course.”

What to watch: For all the environmental pressure growth has created, in recent decades, both rich and poor countries have been able to continue to grow while reducing many pollutants through more efficiency and cleaner energy.

  • Growing while reducing carbon emissions enough to avert dangerous climate change will be tougher, but that’s beginning to happen as well.

The bottom line: To paraphrase Winston Churchill on democracy, the pursuit of growth has its faults, but it still may be the least worst way to organize an economy.

AXIOS



94 Comments on "How stalling growth hurts the planet"

  1. ko phangan surat thani thailand on Fri, 14th Jun 2024 7:38 pm 

    Explore ko phangan surat thani thailand premier real estate destination, featuring luxury villas, beachfront properties, land, and investment opportunities. Your trusted local expert since 2004, specializing in real estate on Thailand’s stunning Emerald Coast.

  2. Uk Number plates on Sat, 15th Jun 2024 9:31 am 

    Thank you for sharing such amazing content with us; it has been incredibly helpful to me!
    4D Number Plates

  3. sellerdash on Thu, 27th Jun 2024 7:13 am 

    SellerDash (Private) Limited is a powerful product hunting tool for Daraz & Lazada. With a wide array of features, SellerDash simplifies your product hunting operations, providing you with the tools you need to succeed in a highly competitive marketplace. Click here : Seller Dash

  4. cassino online on Thu, 22nd Aug 2024 4:51 am 

    Experimente a emoção do cassino online no ZKQQI. Jogue seus jogos favoritos e tenha a chance de ganhar grandes prêmios agora mesmo.

  5. napsgear on Thu, 22nd Aug 2024 11:36 am 

    Discover the trusted source for quality steroids with napsgear. Offering a wide range of products, Napsgear is dedicated to delivering the best in performance-enhancing solutions.

  6. Alchemai on Thu, 29th Aug 2024 11:27 am 

    Discover the essence of sustainable fashion with alchemai, a brand committed to crafting high-quality, eco-friendly clothing that merges style with responsibility.

  7. Tree Kolu on Sat, 31st Aug 2024 4:16 am 

    Someone can have a look at it to know what gold type they should be using for engagement or wedding rings. https://jeweljaunt.com/jewelry-care/solid-gold/what-is-375-585-and-750-in-gold-jewelry/

  8. plumbernearmeservic on Thu, 5th Sep 2024 1:04 am 

    Searching for top-rated plumbing companies near you? Trust Brazos Plumbing in League City for professional residential and commercial plumbing services. Plumbing company’s

  9. anus on Thu, 5th Sep 2024 11:09 am 

    Fresh Love is a vibrant, contemporary brand that embodies passion, creativity, and bold expression through its innovative designs and high-quality products. Known for its stylish apparel and accessories, Fresh Love caters to fashion-forward individuals who embrace a lifestyle of authenticity and love for unique aesthetics. fresh love

  10. anus on Fri, 6th Sep 2024 4:54 am 

    Cheap Web Hosting provides budget-friendly solutions for individuals and businesses looking to establish an online presence without breaking the bank. Despite being affordable, cheap web hosting services often come with essential features such as decent storage, bandwidth, and reliable uptime, making them ideal for small websites, blogs, startups, or personal projects. cheap web hosting

  11. Abdul Qadir on Mon, 9th Sep 2024 12:49 pm 

    Embrace effortless style with the Alchemai Hoodie. Featuring a clean, contemporary design, this hoodie is made from premium materials that offer exceptional comfort and durability. The relaxed fit and soft texture ensure all-day wearability, while the discreet Alchemai emblem adds a subtle yet sophisticated touch. Ideal for both lounging at home and running errands, the Alchemai Hoodie is your go-to for a laid-back look with a refined edge. alchemai Hoodie

  12. anus on Sat, 12th Oct 2024 9:19 am 

    Quality is crucial when building a resume that stands out in today’s competitive job market. Let expert CV services help you craft a job-winning resume that highlights your unique strengths naturally. Boost your chances of landing your dream job with a professionally tailored CV Distribute your CV to hiring managers

  13. Doha curtains on Sat, 19th Oct 2024 8:53 pm 

    At Curtains in Doha, we offer an exquisite selection of window blinds that blend style, privacy, and functionality. Find the perfect custom window blinds for your home or office in Qatar.

  14. anus syed hamid on Sun, 20th Oct 2024 9:58 am 

    Quality is crucial when building a resume that stands out in today’s competitive job market. Let expert CV services help you craft a job-winning resume that highlights your unique strengths naturally. Boost your chances of landing your dream job with a professionally tailored CV Professional resume writing service

  15. mascot parties on Wed, 23rd Oct 2024 5:34 am 

    Experience the best Parties Calgary
    Mascot Party Calgary has to offer. Mascot Parties provides top-quality character entertainment to make your child’s birthday celebration lively and unforgettable.

  16. ASN Digital Marketing on Thu, 21st Nov 2024 2:06 am 

    Elevate your online presence with professional web design by ASN. Affordable, high-quality solutions designed to showcase your brand and attract more customers.
    Professional Web Design by ASN

  17. anus on Sat, 7th Dec 2024 7:41 am 

    O agenție de comunicare ajută brandurile să transmită mesajele cheie. Utilizează strategii integrate pentru a atinge publicul-țintă și a construi relații durabile. Agenție Comunicare

  18. Waves Home on Wed, 11th Dec 2024 7:14 pm 

    Wave Homes LLC was set up with the initial vision of improving overall quality and service standards in property rentals and sales services in Al Mouj Muscat, Muscat Hills and other ITC projects (Integrated Tourism Complexes) established to enable foreigners to invest in and own properties in Oman. We aim at ensuring complete transparency in how customers are managed, streamlining the process and making sure that our customers’ vested interests are protected.

    1 bedroom apartment for rent in al mouj muscat

  19. Angela u on Mon, 23rd Dec 2024 3:22 am 

    Looking to sell your car and get quick cash? Check out Cash for Cars junkyard Edmonton for fast, reliable, and top-dollar offers on your vehicle. Whether it’s running or not, they’ll handle all the towing and paperwork! Highly recommend their service!

  20. Angela on Thu, 26th Dec 2024 2:17 am 

    Looking for top-quality custom homes? Discover Lightstone Homes, known for their exceptional craftsmanship and personalized designs.

  21. surrey geeks on Thu, 26th Dec 2024 2:18 am 

    We offer IT services, business IT support, and expert IT helpdesk solutions in Surrey to keep your systems running smoothly.
    surrey it helpdesk

  22. anus on Sat, 22nd Feb 2025 3:53 pm 

    This is certainly also quite a very good putting up many of us really seasoned hunting by way of. It can be not even close each day we’ve got threat to view a little something. https://fancywin-login.com/

  23. anus on Wed, 26th Feb 2025 3:02 pm 

    This is why it is far better that you can pertinent analysis ahead of producing. It will be possible to post greater article using this method. https://jitabetwin.com/

  24. iptv uk on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 4:39 am 

    Discover the Best iptv uk

  25. iptv uk subscription on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 4:39 am 

    Discover the Best IPTV UK Provider: Say goodbye to costly cables and endless buffering! iptv uk sub

  26. uk iptv subscription on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 5:17 am 

    Discover Best IPTV UK iptv uk subs

  27. iptv xtremehd on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 5:18 am 

    Discover the Best IPTV UK Provider: xtremehd uk

  28. catchontv on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 6:57 pm 

    Discover the Best IPTV UK Provider: Say goodbye to costly cables and endless buffering! iptv CATCHON

  29. iptv catch on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 6:57 pm 

    Discover the Best IPTV UK Provider: Say goodbye to costly cables and endless buffering! CATCHONTV

  30. iptv catchon on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 6:59 pm 

    Catchontv Discover the Best IPTV Usa Provider CATCHONtv IPTV

  31. iptv subscription on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 6:59 pm 

    Catchontv Discover CATCHONtv IPTV

  32. catchon iptv on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 7:00 pm 

    Catchontv Discover CATCHONtv

  33. catch tv on Thu, 27th Feb 2025 7:01 pm 

    Catchontv Discover the Best IPTV Usa Provider CATCHONtv IPTV iptv usa

  34. ss iptv on Fri, 28th Feb 2025 3:15 pm 

    if you’re considering making the switch, take time to explore your options. The world of IPTV is filled with exciting possibilities ss iptv

  35. iptv gamma on Sun, 2nd Mar 2025 3:34 am 

    Gamma IPTV Discover the Best IPTV Gamma Provider Gamma iptv

  36. elon iptv on Wed, 26th Mar 2025 2:11 am 

    IPTV elon Discover the Best IPTV Provider in the Uk IPTV elon

    https://eloniptv4k.com

  37. elon iptv on Wed, 26th Mar 2025 2:12 am 

    Discover the Best IPTV Provider IPTV elon

  38. FYI: TikTok's Purple Ticket is THE hottest thing happening right now. https://vm.tiktok.com/ZShhFsnBN/ on Fri, 6th Jun 2025 4:08 am 

    FYI: TikTok’s Purple Ticket is THE hottest thing happening right now.
    https://vm.tiktok.com/ZShhFsnBN/

  39. study smartly on Fri, 6th Jun 2025 4:30 am 

    Fun + Freebies? Yes please! TikTok Purple Ticket gives out real summer swag. Invite 2+ friends and claim your chance to win a speaker, tumbler, and more!
    https://vm.tiktok.com/ZShhFpBuy/

  40. woodyland on Wed, 11th Jun 2025 9:17 am 

    Scopri un mondo di giochi sicuri e creativi con giocattoli educativi da Woodyland.

  41. yournumberplates on Tue, 14th Oct 2025 10:44 am 

    custom number plates – Explore a wide range of customizable number plates designed to suit your style and meet legal requirements, all at an affordable price.

  42. pupandpearl on Sat, 25th Oct 2025 10:33 am 

    cat clothing – Find cute and comfortable outfits to keep your cat stylish, cozy, and ready for any occasion.

  43. Texasroad on Tue, 16th Dec 2025 2:41 am 

    The Texas Roadhouse Lunch Menu is a great option for a satisfying midday meal. It offers the same bold flavors and quality as the dinner menu, but in portions that are perfect for lunch. With good variety and quick service, it’s an easy choice when you want a filling meal without the long wait.

  44. william on Tue, 16th Dec 2025 4:09 am 

    The Red Robin Dinner Menuoffers a satisfying selection of hearty meals that are perfect for an evening out. From their signature gourmet burgers to chicken dishes, salads, and Donatos® pizzas, the menu provides plenty of variety for different tastes. The ability to customize entrées and pair them with bottomless sides adds extra value to the dining experience. Overall, the dinner menu combines comfort, flavor, and flexibility, making Red Robin a popular choice for relaxed and enjoyable dinners.

1 2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *