by Sixstrings » Thu 30 Oct 2014, 16:23:59
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('Ibon', 'I')t seems to be a ubiquitous aspect of all human cultures to create a religious narrative to explain the dilemma of being a sentient mortal.
Yep, you're right, that's what started it to begin with.
We know for sure that spirituality and religion is a product of evolution, and it is apparently conducive to the species' survival (or was, when it first evolved).
Some of the oldest homo sapien graves have evidence for spirituality and belief in an afterlife, with tools and charms and clothes packed into the grave, as if the deceased will need them in some other place.
I think what started it is just sentience -- no other animal is as sentient and self-aware as we are, so imagine those early homo sapiens with their new big brains and then they see their family members just dying and they realize they will too one day.
Imagine how depressing that sh*t is. And immobilizing. You can't survive if you're depressed that you're gonna die one day, right? So, ergo, it's conducive to survival to get your mind off that sh*t and just believe in an afterlife. Natural selection does not care if heaven is real or not, it only cares that you don't sit around depressed about death and you get out there and survive long enough to have offspring.
$this->bbcode_second_pass_quote('', 'W')e probably have more atheists and agnostics today than at any other time but I doubt seriously than we could eliminate religious beliefs from modern human cultures.
The problem we have now is just that we're stuck with this simplistic old fashioned christianity from pre-science eras and people can't get past Noah's Ark and creationist sillyness and so they discount it all.
People secretly thing it's like believing in santa claus or the easter bunny.
We probably need an evolved christianity to fit modern times, more akin to the ancient gnostic christians, and lose the focus on a "god" that is some guy in the sky that intervenes in your life.
Something more like buddhism, that kind of religion would better serve modern people.
By the way -- I do believe in a sixth sense though, and all that. There's something more to religion than just sentient apes needing to believe in an afterlife. Every ancient culture has its shamen, and spiritual world.
There are some people that have some kind of higher intuition / esp, and these are the priests and shamen in a tribe.
And if you want to get mystical -- quantum mechanics and string theory are about as far out and msytical as it gets. It matches up with buddhism, how all things are one and connected. If you break an atom up to its smaller parts and put them at opposite sides of the universe, and poke one part, the other parts would vibrate in resonance.
So how cool is that. There really is some larger framework connecting everything, that we do not understand as yet.
Lastly, at the end of the day, just the "golden rule" message from christianity and judaism is a good thing, and buddhism is very focused on that. Right living. Doing the right thing. Treating the other as you would yourself. These are all good for society. People really can get "wicked" with how they live their lives. I don't like bible thumpers, but there's a limit you know?
Atheists can have morality too, but the problem there is that there is no one philosophy they are all agreeing on, necessarily. It is helpful to have some kind of moral foundation that everyone agrees on, whether that is christianity or buddhist, etc.
The buddha taught very common sense useful things, like how anything in excess is bad, everything in moderation, and how to detach when you need to, how to accept things in life and accept impermanence, and that others are not different from you and to have compassion. That's all really good stuff. The best of christianity teaches the same values, too.